Status
Call number
Collection
Publication
Description
Fiction. Science Fiction. HTML: The third thrilling book in the increasingly popular Murderbot Diaries, which began with All Systems Red. SciFi's favorite antisocial A.I. is back on a mission. The case against the too-big-to-fail GrayCris Corporation is floundering, and more importantly, authorities are beginning to ask more questions about where Dr. Mensah's SecUnit is. And Murderbot would rather those questions went away. For good. Martha Wells' Rogue Protocol is the third in the Murderbot Diaries series, starring a human-like android who keeps getting sucked back into adventure after adventure, though it just wants to be left alone, away from humanity and small talk. Read Rogue Protocol and find out why Hugo Award winner Ann Leckie wrote "I love Murderbot!".… (more)
User reviews
As usual, and
Of the three books so far, this slightly longer one had pacing most like a Hollywood movie, complete with a bunch of explosions, double-crosses, and a heroic sacrifice. But of course it relied on the characterization and setting established in the previous volumes, and I can hardly imagine how most of this would be communicated cinematically, since the multiplex inhuman sensorium of the construct is one of the important ingredients of the narrative.
I'm still enjoying the series, but it needs to break form in the next book to keep my attention.
NEXT READ: I got a lot more out of the Miki/Murderbot relationship this time. Totally confusing emotions of resentfulness/rage/disgust at someone who didn't do anything but be sort of like you only more innocent and trusting, yup. Do you ever read something and the author leaves you to fill in the gaps in the narrative like it should be obvious and you can't? I feel like Murderbot here, I don't know what those emotions are or what they are for and I would like someone to explain, please. I'm aware Murderbot would like that too, which makes it less frustrating.
Fun, and that's not such a bad thing.
In “Rogue Protocol” by Martha Wells
Is the SecUnit Pro- or Anti-Wittgenstein?
Wittgenstein is often cited by believers in the possibility of more or less "sentient" AI. He is cited because he seems
So far, so good Martha: Pro-Wittgenstein.
But nonetheless there is good reason to believe that though they are distributed, implicit, and emergent, what these machines develop are indeed representations of statistical properties and classificatory schema gleaned from iterative presentations of data. The machines could even be given the ability to inspect or "represent" these representations; and it is this level of meta-representation which is often said to be necessary (and sufficient?) for self-awareness. Meta-representations are used in human and machine cognition for example in "chunking" and classifying operations. Sentience does not necessarily follow from the capacity to represent one's representations. What does follow from meta-representation is a "picture picture", precisely what Wittgenstein warned us to be wary of when "inspecting" our own perceptual/conceptual processes.
Do you remember what Wittgenstein called "seeing-as"? We can see the duck-rabbit as a duck or a rabbit, and context can make us more likely to perceive one or the other (e.g. the rabbit aspect apparently jumps out at more viewers around about Easter time). Now in all likelihood a machine could be trained to use contextual cues for seeing the duck or the rabbit contextually. But this is simply contextualisation by data addition. The machine is trained to take proximate data points into account when it makes it decision about what it is "seeing". It is not "true" seeing-as, as there is nothing in the machine which sees the seeing. Even meta-representations in a machine are just hierarchically structured representations. They are the "picture picture" without the picturer. That’s what the Murderbot embodies in a fictionalised way. I imagine that the microwave doesn't know that three minutes have passed - but actually neither do we. What we get via Wells is that we feel the Murderbot knows. We have the sense of knowing that it/she really knows. I have read arguments saying "oh but our sense of ourselves as knowing subjects is illusory" - in what sense (excuse the homophone) is this the case? Our sense of self is said to be an illusion, but still we have it. Can we not equally say that the Murderbot’s self just is its sense of itself/herself? Since the Murderbot undeniably experiences a sense of self then what does it mean to say that that sense is itself illusory? How can an experience of an experience be illusory? This time we’ve got Miki to give the Murderbot some further contextualisation of self which is quite different from what happened in the last two installments (good fiction works extremely well by using opposites.) The Murderbot’s experiences of the external world can be illusory because its/her senses can be deceived so that they don't correspond to the "objective" reality of what they appear to represent it/her. Yet, experience is already inherently subjective. How can we compare it to itself and say that the comparison is false or even falsifiable? How can the Murderbot’s experience of the Murderbot’s experience be anything other than the Murderbot’s experience?
You see, it’s through the Murderbot’s snarky internal monologue that we can experience its/her experience and it’s just how things seem to it/her, no more and no less. It makes no sense to say that it/she was mistaken when it seemed to it/her that this is how things seemed to it/her, or that in fact they seemed some other way, only to it/her it seemed that they seemed how they seemed... Isn't this just marvellous that we can get this kind of thing out of a SF story?
NB: “It” is the personal pronoun the Murderbot uses to refer to itself/herself. In my mind, the Murderbot is a she. Not sure why. It just feels like that.
Murderbot is still trying to gather evidence against GrayCris Corporation, the cut-throat company that is so willing to murder its competitors in the name of increased profits. Murderbot is still officially a rogue SecUnit on the run, and as such, he’s forced to live in the shadows. Still, most often by teaming up with other artificial-intelligence creations, he manages to make his way from planet to planet without being captured.
That doesn’t mean that it’s been easy, or that it’s going to be, because Murderbot’s big weakness keeps getting him in trouble. He still has a soft spot in his “heart” for humans, and he keeps stumbling into situations where several rather naïve human scientists have to be protected from the evil GrayCris Corporation. And, since Murderbot is heading in the same direction, he finds it impossible to keep himself from taking the humans under his wing – whether they always realize it or not.
But all of that is part of the problem I had with Rogue Protocol. Wells assumes that all of her readers are already going to have Murderbot’s backstory, so she doesn’t spend much time developing the book’s newest characters (granted, they are only passing through, anyway) or the backstory. Consequently, Murderbot does not come across as nearly the compassionate and ironically funny character he is in the first two books in the series. And then there’s yet another claustrophobic jaunt down long hallways dotted with dangerous intersections, as Murderbot frantically tries to get his humans to safety while fighting one combat bot after another.
The best part of Rogue Protocol is Miki, the little bot that just wants a friend like himself. Even as Miki is recklessly is throwing his body into every battle alongside Murderbot (despite being hopelessly overmatched), he’s more concerned with hurting Murderbot’s feelings than with the danger to himself. He loves his humans, and they love him, but Miki truly treasures his first friendship with someone “like him.”
Bottom Line: It seems that the publisher of the Murderbot Diaries made more of a business decision than a literary one with the way the company handled Rogue Protocol. This one could, and probably should, have been the second half of its predecessor, Artificial Condition, even though it would have probably seemed a little repetitive that way. As it was, two Murderbot Diary novellas and one Murderbot Diary novel were published in 2018, rather than what could easily have been two novels.
In Rogue Protocol, Murderbot continues to search for what it wants and to find a purpose. Although it is still difficult for Murderbot to interact with humans, it feels protective of those it runs across, blaming its feelings on previous programming. By periodically breaking the fourth wall, Murderbot brings the reader more deeply into its thoughts, making it easy to empathize with the character. Another good entry in the Murderbot Diaries series.
In this installment, Murderbot hitches a ride through space to Milu, the planet where he thinks he can gather evidence to help Dr. Mensah, who we met in the first book of the series. In the first book, Dr. Mensah’s group (and Murderbot’s clients) were attacked by the GrayCris Corporation, and now GrayCris is being investigated. As Murderbot explains, GrayCris was willing to kill bunches of humans for exclusive (and illegal) access to the mineral and possibly biological remains of sentient alien civilizations. Dr. Mensah needs proof of GrayCris’s nefarious operations, and Murderbot thinks he can find it at Milu. It would not only help her, but perhaps distract journalists from their concurrent preoccupation with “that stray SecUnit” - i.e., Murderbot.
So Murderbot contrived a scheme to get to Milu, pretending to be a Security Consultant for a new group of clients headed that way. During the process, Murderbot gets into the usual existence-threatening scrapes, and encounters the now-usual moral dilemmas, which in truth, no SecUnit should be having.
Evaluation: Murderbot has no gender, but I think of it as a “he”; perhaps that is just a reflection of my personal bias. No one in the books have that same problem. They are of all races and genders and don’t tend to categorize any others, whether human or not.
Murderbot has a variety of super-tech capabilities, but seems very human, indeed. It is more powerful than Lee Child’s Jack Reacher character, although reminiscent of him in ways, but amusing, seems more “human” than Jack. Best of all, Murderbot’s dry sense of humor, sardonic wit, and constant existential angst are supremely entertaining. I love this series!
Oh my poor, sweet Murderbot. Your pain is real to me because Author Wells is skilled in the art of inflicting pain in innocent readers. Best of the three stories by a good margin.
Murderbot continues its quest to fully understand the horrible life it's led as a slave, one sentient
I didn’t have the combat stealth module anyway (I had never been upgraded with it, probably due to...the whole “killing all the clients” thing, go figure)...
***
Who knew being a heartless killing machine would present so many moral dilemmas. (Yes, that was sarcasm.)
***
The core cutter had powered up and accessed my feed to deliver a canned warning and a handy set of directions. Why yes, I did want to disengage the safety protocols, thanks for asking.
The issue at hand this time, the reason Murderbot sweet-talked a fairly basic pilot bot into allowing it aboard a human-infested transport to a far outpost on the Corporation Rim...pause to appreciate that as Murderbot's quest for information (what humans call answers) to process what and why it became Murderbot in the first place that it travels in space beyond the reach of the corporation-first norms into low-security humans-first territory...is to collect more data on GrayCris. These corporate malefactors ("We were talking about GrayCris here, whose company motto seemed to be “profit by killing everybody and taking their stuff,” thinks Murderbot) are in the middle of a lawsuit war with Dr. Mensah and the entire Preservation team that bought Murderbot in [All Systems Red].
The discoveries Murderbot makes are, well, unsurprising in that malefeasance and lawbreaking are involved. They are appalling in that corporate skulduggery explicitly involves murdering people to save the corporation money. Author Wells doesn't look on a safe, secure, "prosperous" world with no privacy and less respect for human dignity with the eye of faith. She sees what she sees and reports back to us. I mean, it's all a story, right, but it's not based on nothing. Is it.
So Murderbot visits beyond the Corporation Rim to discover what it suspects is bombshell information. Murderbot wants to help the human that bought it not in order to use it but in order to stop it being used. Murderbot applied its sentience to leave, it's not proper to say "escape," Dr. Mensah to begin its quest for sapience without knowing in advance that...
...apparently once you start, you can’t just stop. I wasn’t going to just send the geo pod data to Dr. Mensah. I was taking it to her personally. I was going back. Then I laid down on the floor and started Rise and Fall of Sanctuary Moon from episode one.
Murderbot's heading home. Family needs it. And Family comes first.
The interactions with the pet robot are probably the best part of this novella, murderbot realising that humans and robots can have quite complicated relationships even when it doesn't really want to acknowledge it's capabilities regarding emotion and relationships. There's a lot of ret-conning of it's abilities and grating of special powers technology wise, especially in hacking other systems that isn't very believable.
Short, fun, but best regarded as part of a novel that contains all four short stories in one.
So it's off to the site of a failed terraforming project GrayCris was involved in, where very
That's not how it works out. Instead, Murderbot finds itself protecting Dr. Dawn Abenna, her "pet bot," Micky, and the rest of her team. Abenna's team already has hired human security consultants, but Murderbot doesn't think anyone should rely on human security consultants rather than SecUnits, and, well, beyond that its reasons may not be entirely clear to itself. There is the problem of keeping Micky quiet about its presence and activities, but it knows there are different solutions to that problem...
Murderbot continues to be a complete delight. Recommended.
I bought this audiobook.
In Rogue Protocol, Murderbot continues to pull on the threads indicting the GrayCris Corporation. Murderbot’s own existence is less of a secret than it once was which is drawing unwanted attention. Finding answers is leading Murderbot to more remote locations which increases the danger of discovery. Murderbot heads to a suspicious abandoned terraforming operation in search of information that would indict GrayCris. The search turns up unexpected discoveries, as well as unanticipated danger.
Murderbot is such a wonderful character. A non-human character who is more than the limits of its programming who, despite an ongoing desire to just enjoy its television shows, desires to be more, to know itself and who has developed a moral compass that defies simple logic. Rogue Protocol introduces us to a new set of human characters along with the humanoid robot Miki. Once again the supporting AI characters in these books defy expectations with their complexity and, ironically, their humanity.
Rogue Protocol is another great entry in the series. Plenty of action, a great story, and thoughtful character creation and development. I can’t wait to see where the next novella takes us and I’m beyond excited to learn that a full-length Murderbot novel is in our future. This is a great book not to be missed by Murderbot fans and if you aren’t already a fan, why not? Pick up these books! You won’t be disappointed. Highly recommended.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publishe
I love me some Murderbot. The first book absolutely charmed me with its balance of smart action and know-how with a sentient security bot with an obsession with human entertainment shows. I dove into this third novella, Rogue Protocol, having not
To my joy, it was very easy to follow along with Murderbot. Actually, I think someone could start at this book and they would be able to follow the story quite well. I was recently reminded of the term "competence porn," and I think that's an appropriate term for why I enjoy these novellas so much. Murderbot is fantastic at their job, and that's a joy to read. The actions flow steady and fast, full of sci-fi twists, and Murderbot's exasperated frustration and obsession with humans made me smile often as I read.
If there was one thing good about this situation, it was reinforcing how great my decisions to (a) hack my
This is a fast-paced, suspenseful novella. I liked how it continues Murderbot’s personal journey, working out how what it means to have agency and how to relate to others as an independent AI, and how the events sets things up for the next book. I didn’t find the story quite as delightful as the first two, perhaps because Murderbot is less attached -- and thus, I was less attached -- to those it is working with. And Murderbot is more confident about pretending to be something it is not and being part of a team.
I like that Murderbot starts quoting from its favourite serial in high-pressure situations. My favourite bits were mostly connected to Murderbot’s love of serials.
Murderbot wants to find
I really enjoyed seeing Murderbot interact with Miki who was a very different kind of bot. Murderbot has seen people at their worst and expects for problems to occur while Miki has been treated like a trusted member of the group and seems rather innocent in its manner of thinking. I really enjoyed being inside Murderbot's head as it worked to process a solution for the problem at hand. I can't wait to start reading the next installment.