Status
Call number
Genres
Collection
Publication
Description
Alice Raikes takes a train from London to Scotland to visit her family, but when she gets there she witnesses something so shocking that she insists on returning to London immediately. A few hours later, Alice is lying in a coma after an accident that may or may not have been a suicide attempt. Alice's family gathers at her bedside and as they wait, argue, and remember, long-buried tensions emerge. The more they talk, the more they seem to conceal. Alice, meanwhile, slides between varying levels of consciousness, recalling her past and a love affair that recently ended. A riveting story that skips through time and interweaves multiple points of view, After You'd Gone is a novel of stunning psychological depth and marks the debut of a major literary talent.… (more)
User reviews
From this point, the novel meanders through time, from the point of Alice's parents' engagment to the near present, and the focal point continually shifts--sometimes it's Alice, sometimes her mother Ann or her grandmother Elspeth, sometimes one of her sisters, Kirsty or Beth. As the family keeps a vigil by Alice's bedside, secrets, regrets, and lost opportunities are slowly revealed, and we come to understand just what brought Alice to this point.
I enjoyed O'Farrell's The Vanishing of Esme Lennox, but this one tops it by far.
The novel proceeds in various tenses, voices, and points of view, peeling off layer after layer of Alice's story, showing us that things are never quite as simple as they seem. After You'd Gone is many things: a story about true love, about family, about loss, about grief, and about healing. All of these things are beautifully rendered in a style that deceives readers into thinking that maybe they aren't all that involved in the story only to find that they've been so wrapped up in the web of Alice's life, that the core of the story is all the more gripping and heart-wrenching.
At first, I found the story's style of stringing together seemingly unrelated vignettes into larger chapters to be difficult, but as I came closer and closer to the end of the novel, I was stunned at how effective this tactic had been in helping me to know Alice inside and out and to become emotionally engaged with her. What seems so haphazard is, in truth, a surprisingly well-crafted narrative. In After You'd Gone, Maggie O'Farrell has crafted an incredible story that takes us into all the highs and lows of her character's life. All the time, O'Farrell manages to stealthily manipulate emotions without ever being cheesy or melodramatic. She is a master of not just telling but showing us her story - capturing the awkwardness of the beginning of a relationship, the blossoming of love, and the intense pain of grief and heartbreak. Maggie O'Farrell has an astonishing grasp of emotions and the human condition. This novel is beautiful, heart-breaking, and not to be missed.
Overall, After You'd Gone is a light and entertaining read, but the major plot twist isn't properly concealed and the dialogue has a B-grade, soap opera feel to it.
I
With hindsight, the gradual unfolding of the story is in some ways rather nice. There is a sense of suspense that builds up to some (perhaps predictable) revelations, and Alice is a quirky character who occasionally shares an insight or a perspective on people or life that I did enjoy.
Perhaps most importantly, life often is a string of disjointed events, and it’s up to each of us to come up with our own connecting narratives.
So maybe my criticism is overly harsh, but I still felt as if this book just didn’t really do much for me at all.
'After You'd Gone' is the story of Alice, who steps in front of a car near the beginning of the book. She falls into a coma, and the book alternates between periods in her life - her childhood, university, and
Like in "The Distance Between Us', there is an underlying mystery to be solved. Was Alice trying to commit suicide? What did she see that may have made her want to do so? Where does the 'he' of the title go to?
There's a huge emotional impact to this book - it's heartbreaking. This, I think, is partly because of the men O'Farrell writes: they are the type of men any female would dream of meeting, and I found myself thinking jealous and bitter thoughts about the luck of her heroines, and feeling devastated by their loss.
After only two books though, I see a stereotype emerging with O'Farrell's male and female characters. Where do men such as these exist, outside the world of fiction? And does a heroine always need to be a feisty yet beautiful outsider (she was also an Edinburgh to London transplant in both books) with the remarkable good fortune of having decent men fall in love with her instantly?
Aside from my strange emotional reaction to O'Farrell's books, I can say that I thoroughly enjoyed both of them. They are well-written, thoughtful and suspenseful.
I knew by page 80 that I would finish it - and
But there was something about Alice. When she meets her John and they muddle their way into a relationship. There’s something about his doggedness, her seeming initial reluctance to be a part of it, then it grows into that sweetness of love, bolstered by their determination to be together despite disapproval. Their immense, heady, head-in-the-clouds love. That was what made me want to carry on. That was what took my own heart a little bit. This relationship, this character of Alice, these things creep under your skin and
The story begins with Alice, heading out on the train to Edinburgh to see her sisters. But something happens and she decides to head back to London. She steps out into the street and is hit by a car. As she lies in a coma in hospital, the narrative, as I had mentioned earlier*, flits from the present to the past, unravelling the circumstances that have led up to this day. This involves her mother, her grandmother, her sisters, and her John.
This story has stayed with me, and everytime I think of it, I feel strangely overwhelmed. There is so much emotion and sentiment in this story. Perhaps it’s a little melodramatic, but it is very moving, and beautifully and sharply written.
I look up O’Farrell’s bibliography and realised that this was her first novel. I can’t wait to read the rest of her books!
But there was something about Alice. When she meets her John and they muddle their way into a relationship. There’s something about his doggedness, her seeming initial reluctance to be a part of it, then it grows into that sweetness of love, bolstered by their determination to be together despite disapproval. Their immense, heady, head-in-the-clouds love. That was what made me want to carry on. That was what took my own heart a little bit. This relationship, this character of Alice, these things creep under your skin and
The story begins with Alice, heading out on the train to Edinburgh to see her sisters. But something happens and she decides to head back to London. She steps out into the street and is hit by a car. As she lies in a coma in hospital, the narrative, as I had mentioned earlier*, flits from the present to the past, unravelling the circumstances that have led up to this day. This involves her mother, her grandmother, her sisters, and her John.
This story has stayed with me, and everytime I think of it, I feel strangely overwhelmed. There is so much emotion and sentiment in this story. Perhaps it’s a little melodramatic, but it is very moving, and beautifully and sharply written.
I look up O’Farrell’s bibliography and realised that this was her first novel. I can’t wait to read the rest of her books!