Status
Available
Call number
Collection
Publication
Little, Brown Books for Young Readers (2009), Edition: 1, Hardcover, 352 pages
Description
In late nineteenth-century New York state, wealthy sixteen-year-old twin sisters Lia and Alice Milthorpe find that they are on opposite sides of an ancient prophecy that has destroyed their parents and seeks to do even more harm.
User reviews
LibraryThing member stephxsu
After the deaths of their parents, twins Alice and Lia discover that an ancient prophecy will put them against one another. The prophecy states that one sister is the guardian of peace between this world and the Otherworld, while the other is the conduit through which the monsters of the Otherworld
But which sister is which? As Lia struggles to come to terms with her own destiny, she is forced to realize that the sister she knew all her life may have always been a dangerous mystery. With newfound allies, Lia plunges further into the story of the prophecy in order to save the world from ruin at the hands of the Lost Souls.
PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS begins a trilogy that speaks of olden times, musty secrets, and shadowy danger everywhere you turn. Michelle Zink sets the mood extremely well: the threat of darkness lurks on every page, and I kept on picturing the story running through my head in black and white and sepia. This insistence on a lurking danger makes the story all the more suspenseful and will keep you reading, frantically flipping the pages as if that will release some of the tension.
This book is mostly exposition for the promise of more action, more peril in future books. Because of that, readers who crave nonstop action will have difficulty getting into this book. The reading is worth it, however, as the prophecy is intricately created and fascinatingly complex. I have no idea how Michelle made the ominous prophecy so captivating, but she does.
I would like to see more character development in the future novels. Because the story is told from Lia’s first-person point of view, I sometimes had trouble understanding how all the characters came to be who they are, and how their stories and personalities are interconnected. In particular, I’m curious to see Alice develop into more than just a suggestion of the “wicked sister;” she seems like such a fascinatingly evil character that I would’ve loved to see how she thinks, how she became that way!
Perhaps the most striking part of PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS, though, is its unpredictability. Michelle defies conventional storytelling and adds surprising twists and events that, in retrospect, seem as if they belonged there all along. This book is no happily-ever-after tale; Lia’s losses are truly tragic and thus poignant. Michelle understands that triumph hardly ever occurs without losses, some of which are heartbreaking.
All in all, PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS is a promising start to a trilogy that will appeal to fans of gothic literature or dark historical fiction with a hint of the occult. I look forward to reading more about where the prophecy takes Lia and the rest of the characters.
Show More
can travel into our world.But which sister is which? As Lia struggles to come to terms with her own destiny, she is forced to realize that the sister she knew all her life may have always been a dangerous mystery. With newfound allies, Lia plunges further into the story of the prophecy in order to save the world from ruin at the hands of the Lost Souls.
PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS begins a trilogy that speaks of olden times, musty secrets, and shadowy danger everywhere you turn. Michelle Zink sets the mood extremely well: the threat of darkness lurks on every page, and I kept on picturing the story running through my head in black and white and sepia. This insistence on a lurking danger makes the story all the more suspenseful and will keep you reading, frantically flipping the pages as if that will release some of the tension.
This book is mostly exposition for the promise of more action, more peril in future books. Because of that, readers who crave nonstop action will have difficulty getting into this book. The reading is worth it, however, as the prophecy is intricately created and fascinatingly complex. I have no idea how Michelle made the ominous prophecy so captivating, but she does.
I would like to see more character development in the future novels. Because the story is told from Lia’s first-person point of view, I sometimes had trouble understanding how all the characters came to be who they are, and how their stories and personalities are interconnected. In particular, I’m curious to see Alice develop into more than just a suggestion of the “wicked sister;” she seems like such a fascinatingly evil character that I would’ve loved to see how she thinks, how she became that way!
Perhaps the most striking part of PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS, though, is its unpredictability. Michelle defies conventional storytelling and adds surprising twists and events that, in retrospect, seem as if they belonged there all along. This book is no happily-ever-after tale; Lia’s losses are truly tragic and thus poignant. Michelle understands that triumph hardly ever occurs without losses, some of which are heartbreaking.
All in all, PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS is a promising start to a trilogy that will appeal to fans of gothic literature or dark historical fiction with a hint of the occult. I look forward to reading more about where the prophecy takes Lia and the rest of the characters.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Tinasbookreviews
Set in the 1800’s, The Prophecy opens under the gloom of a funeral. The burial of Lia and Alice’s father sets the tone for this dreary, gothic setting amidst the story's alarming tale of lies, betrayals and the supernatural. A “seemingly unending” portrait unfolds of an author’s take of
I truly felt sucked into the atmosphere of this book. Zink’s talent for detail felt real to me, I could almost hear the river crash upon the cliffs of the Milthorpes’ home; hear the girls heavy skirts swish as they walked the halls. Feel the dreary weather seep from the pages and be on the edge of my seat waiting for something to pop out. Even with the prophecy centering around angels and the otherworld, no otherworld characters play a huge role in this story, the plot mostly centers around the twins weird relationship and Lia's self-discoverys.
Show More
the mysterious legends from the Book of Enoch. I found the Sisters story a more original take on fallen angels and ancient mythology. The story has a classic written feel told from Lia’s perspective; she is a strong and convincing character. From the grief over her parents, to the love she has for James- her development of strength to face adversity was intriguing.I truly felt sucked into the atmosphere of this book. Zink’s talent for detail felt real to me, I could almost hear the river crash upon the cliffs of the Milthorpes’ home; hear the girls heavy skirts swish as they walked the halls. Feel the dreary weather seep from the pages and be on the edge of my seat waiting for something to pop out. Even with the prophecy centering around angels and the otherworld, no otherworld characters play a huge role in this story, the plot mostly centers around the twins weird relationship and Lia's self-discoverys.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Ziaria
This was a wonderful, dark, Gothic mystery and I loved it! I can't wait to read book 2 when it comes out. I want to see how this story unfolds as Lia moves on to her next stop in her journey. I enjoyed how Michelle's storyline is pitting sibling against sibling in a race between good and evil. She
The era in which this story is told is what really makes the story work. I'm not sure it would work at all in any other era or at least not nearly as well. I was pulled into a dark, cold, dreary world where the buildings are old and the cold seeps in no matter where you roam. Michelle did an awesome job of creating the world in which her story is told. I could see the rooms of the sprawling estate and it's grounds, the carriages they rode to town in, the lake, I could almost feel the rushing water. I can picture how the town looks and feels. I love it when story comes to life like that for me.
The story weaves through your mind creating a visual of a world I can't wait to go back to. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who likes the feel of a dark, Gothic book full of mystery and intrigue.
Show More
has a unique take on this particular storyline.The era in which this story is told is what really makes the story work. I'm not sure it would work at all in any other era or at least not nearly as well. I was pulled into a dark, cold, dreary world where the buildings are old and the cold seeps in no matter where you roam. Michelle did an awesome job of creating the world in which her story is told. I could see the rooms of the sprawling estate and it's grounds, the carriages they rode to town in, the lake, I could almost feel the rushing water. I can picture how the town looks and feels. I love it when story comes to life like that for me.
The story weaves through your mind creating a visual of a world I can't wait to go back to. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who likes the feel of a dark, Gothic book full of mystery and intrigue.
Show Less
LibraryThing member rebecca191
Sixteen-year-old Lia Milthorpe and her twin sister, Alice, have never been close. But when their father dies, leaving the girls and their younger brother Henry orphans, disturbing events begin to happen that separate the girls even further. A strange mark appears on Lia’s wrist, and Alice is
Soon, Lia learns that she and Alice are part of an ancient prophecy that makes them mortal enemies. They both have a role to play - one good, one evil. And if events are not stopped, it could bring about the end of the world. Unsure where to turn with her parents dead, her sister now her enemy, and unable to confide in James, the young man she loves, Lia must find a way to avert tragedy and end the prophecy.
Set in 19th century New York, Prophecy of the Sisters is a chilling supernatural story with the feel of an old Gothic novel. I really liked that this book was a young adult fantasy set in historical times, which set it apart from other teen paranormal fiction that is mostly set in the present day. The ending is quite the cliffhanger, and I can’t wait to read the other two books in this trilogy to see how the story concludes. Unfortunately, the next book will not be out until August 2010, and I’m not sure how I’ll wait that long! I would definitely recommend this book to readers looking for an unusual young adult fantasy, you will not be disappointed.
Show More
acting strange and even more distant.Soon, Lia learns that she and Alice are part of an ancient prophecy that makes them mortal enemies. They both have a role to play - one good, one evil. And if events are not stopped, it could bring about the end of the world. Unsure where to turn with her parents dead, her sister now her enemy, and unable to confide in James, the young man she loves, Lia must find a way to avert tragedy and end the prophecy.
Set in 19th century New York, Prophecy of the Sisters is a chilling supernatural story with the feel of an old Gothic novel. I really liked that this book was a young adult fantasy set in historical times, which set it apart from other teen paranormal fiction that is mostly set in the present day. The ending is quite the cliffhanger, and I can’t wait to read the other two books in this trilogy to see how the story concludes. Unfortunately, the next book will not be out until August 2010, and I’m not sure how I’ll wait that long! I would definitely recommend this book to readers looking for an unusual young adult fantasy, you will not be disappointed.
Show Less
LibraryThing member oliviawilliams
Prophecy of the Sisters by Michelle Zink took quite awhile to get through. Not a quick read at all. I had really high expectations for this book. And it disappointed completely. I feel really bad and sad for writing a sort of bad review. But I can't help it. There are just parts in this book that
I will be reading the next book, but I will not rush out to buy or read it as soon as it comes out. I will admit, I'm interested about the ending. But there were parts that were just so confusing, I didn't understand anything. Also, about the whole James and Lia thing? I don't understand how they are in love with each other. What is their relationship base of? I wish the story could of started how she meet him in town or something and their relationship started there, not before the book started. I just didn't feel the chemistry. It always seemed James just showed up at random times, and then all of sudden he would be gone for a long period of time with no explanation of his whereabouts?
This style type isn't for me. But maybe for other people, I had read many excellent reviews on it. I recommend it to people who are in love with "A Great and Terrible Beauty", which beats this book hand downs. I am in love with that book :) But I do find it sort of the same gene. The one thing I loved in the book was Lia and Alice's power to Dream Travel. They go through the world in their dreams, which sounds so wonderful to be able to do. I thought I woud end with something I liked :) But if you think the story, sounds interesting by all means do read it and give it try. This book was just not for me.
Show More
were just boring to me, and I didn't care for. But, there were a lot of good parts. Mostly towards the end. No where near the beginning. The reason why I decided to read this was probably because everyone was talking about how amazing it was and also the story just sounded intriguing.The main idea and story plot for this book is expeditionary creative. I like the idea of the keys being people and Lia and Sonia going out on a quest, with Louisa following. I will be reading the next book, but I will not rush out to buy or read it as soon as it comes out. I will admit, I'm interested about the ending. But there were parts that were just so confusing, I didn't understand anything. Also, about the whole James and Lia thing? I don't understand how they are in love with each other. What is their relationship base of? I wish the story could of started how she meet him in town or something and their relationship started there, not before the book started. I just didn't feel the chemistry. It always seemed James just showed up at random times, and then all of sudden he would be gone for a long period of time with no explanation of his whereabouts?
This style type isn't for me. But maybe for other people, I had read many excellent reviews on it. I recommend it to people who are in love with "A Great and Terrible Beauty", which beats this book hand downs. I am in love with that book :) But I do find it sort of the same gene. The one thing I loved in the book was Lia and Alice's power to Dream Travel. They go through the world in their dreams, which sounds so wonderful to be able to do. I thought I woud end with something I liked :) But if you think the story, sounds interesting by all means do read it and give it try. This book was just not for me.
Show Less
LibraryThing member flamingo1325
I loved this book- especially that it was a tale that could be set in any time but is being done in the 1800s. Zink has set up the world nicely and rarely did I fall into the comforting lure of modern times and imagine the events taken place in 2009. The dialect and way things were said made it
There were plenty of twists thrown into this tale- some of which I predicted and some that I didn’t and others that were painfully obvious but I simply didn’t put any thought into them. And I have made a revelation while reading this story which again is likely ostensibly blatant but I chalk it up to the fact that I am actually working on my own trilogy now. Several of those twists, in retrospect, are completely logical and you can even go wow, that makes sense. And yet, as a reader who has no idea of what is coming- I find myself grinning and gasping and falling more into the story with each revealed caveat and facet. As a writer, however, I find myself planning things out for my own trilogy and rethinking it, wondering if it’s too blatant and too easy and too, well, logical. But reading this book- now that I am starting to look more at plot lines and how things tie together and hints early on that become something later- I realize that things are often supposed to be logical and make sense. What seems obvious to me as the writer is not necessarily obvious to the reader and perhaps I have just been delayed in such a realization but it has only made me appreciate such twists more and I wonder if perhaps the reason I find myself grinning so much after finishing this novel is for this reason- that newfound appreciation- or if it is just that it is a well written, well thought out novel.
Whether everyone else knew it or not that this is the first in a trilogy, I didn’t prior to reading it and only when I finished it did I come to know that. In a way, I think that made me love the story more. Although there is no huge blow out in this book, the pacing was great and the way the reader followed each clue and each step- learned more about the prophecy right there with Lia made it even more amazing in my opinion. Many things I didn’t consider happening because Lia didn’t consider it. It was as shocking to her as it was to me and I love writing styles such as that. I am now very much looking forward to the next installment in this trilogy and am actually glad to know it isn’t going to be over yet. I have a better idea of what the next book is meant for, and now know to expect the final bang in the third and final book.
Overall, I actually really did like Lia. She is confused and scared but she is not dim witted or a coward. She faces her prophecy and everything around her as bravely as she can and she cares immensely for those around her. She loves book and she takes comfort in her family. She is protective of her brother, and a friend to her sister even if that same sister stands on the other side of this prophecy- if that sister is something more sinister and damaging. Her actions make sense- I never found myself questioning why she was doing something. In ways, I could relate to her (as much as you can relate to someone living 200 years before you). I also think this story is made even better because while it very much centers around both Lia and Alice, it is in Lia’s perspective- the reader is inherently biased towards her side of the story, her plight- but it gives me plenty to think about. To wonder about the events we don’t know about- the things even Lia is in the dark towards- that have led Alice to where she is.
I give this book 4 stars only because while I did enjoy it and fell into it, it didn’t absolutely grip me and make me think about nothing but it, where I lose sleep staying up to read and where I pull it out at every chance I get. In all truthfulness, I think that is just because this book centers around unraveling the prophecy and understanding both it and Lia’s place within it. It is a good mystery- a great puzzle to figure out- but it also lacks mind stealing action. I would not ask for that high volume of action to be in this book- it does not belong there- but unfortunately, I believe that is why it didn’t totally grip me. Am I going to get the next book as soon as it comes out? Absolutely. Do I see the next book and especially the third being full of action and gripping me to it? Definitely.
Show More
clear it was not modern times, along with passing references to having hot water brought, stable boys and even travel by a carriage. Though I cannot explain why, somehow the era in which this story was set made it even more fulfilling to me.There were plenty of twists thrown into this tale- some of which I predicted and some that I didn’t and others that were painfully obvious but I simply didn’t put any thought into them. And I have made a revelation while reading this story which again is likely ostensibly blatant but I chalk it up to the fact that I am actually working on my own trilogy now. Several of those twists, in retrospect, are completely logical and you can even go wow, that makes sense. And yet, as a reader who has no idea of what is coming- I find myself grinning and gasping and falling more into the story with each revealed caveat and facet. As a writer, however, I find myself planning things out for my own trilogy and rethinking it, wondering if it’s too blatant and too easy and too, well, logical. But reading this book- now that I am starting to look more at plot lines and how things tie together and hints early on that become something later- I realize that things are often supposed to be logical and make sense. What seems obvious to me as the writer is not necessarily obvious to the reader and perhaps I have just been delayed in such a realization but it has only made me appreciate such twists more and I wonder if perhaps the reason I find myself grinning so much after finishing this novel is for this reason- that newfound appreciation- or if it is just that it is a well written, well thought out novel.
Whether everyone else knew it or not that this is the first in a trilogy, I didn’t prior to reading it and only when I finished it did I come to know that. In a way, I think that made me love the story more. Although there is no huge blow out in this book, the pacing was great and the way the reader followed each clue and each step- learned more about the prophecy right there with Lia made it even more amazing in my opinion. Many things I didn’t consider happening because Lia didn’t consider it. It was as shocking to her as it was to me and I love writing styles such as that. I am now very much looking forward to the next installment in this trilogy and am actually glad to know it isn’t going to be over yet. I have a better idea of what the next book is meant for, and now know to expect the final bang in the third and final book.
Overall, I actually really did like Lia. She is confused and scared but she is not dim witted or a coward. She faces her prophecy and everything around her as bravely as she can and she cares immensely for those around her. She loves book and she takes comfort in her family. She is protective of her brother, and a friend to her sister even if that same sister stands on the other side of this prophecy- if that sister is something more sinister and damaging. Her actions make sense- I never found myself questioning why she was doing something. In ways, I could relate to her (as much as you can relate to someone living 200 years before you). I also think this story is made even better because while it very much centers around both Lia and Alice, it is in Lia’s perspective- the reader is inherently biased towards her side of the story, her plight- but it gives me plenty to think about. To wonder about the events we don’t know about- the things even Lia is in the dark towards- that have led Alice to where she is.
I give this book 4 stars only because while I did enjoy it and fell into it, it didn’t absolutely grip me and make me think about nothing but it, where I lose sleep staying up to read and where I pull it out at every chance I get. In all truthfulness, I think that is just because this book centers around unraveling the prophecy and understanding both it and Lia’s place within it. It is a good mystery- a great puzzle to figure out- but it also lacks mind stealing action. I would not ask for that high volume of action to be in this book- it does not belong there- but unfortunately, I believe that is why it didn’t totally grip me. Am I going to get the next book as soon as it comes out? Absolutely. Do I see the next book and especially the third being full of action and gripping me to it? Definitely.
Show Less
LibraryThing member faith42love
I loved this book of twin sisters, Alice and Leah. As the title indicates, the sisters play a part in a prophecy. One is the guardian and one is the gate, while it is one sister responsibility to keep the souls of Samil on the other side it is the duty of the other sister to release as many souls
The Prophecy of the Sisters is very poetic in its style, Zink does an amazing job of using beautiful words to describe every little action of the story. I am sure listening to the audio version of the book something to do with my opinion. The book was read by actress Eliza Dushku and she did a great job but at first it was weird trying to get her face and the characters she plays on TV out of my head. I am a huge fan of hers. Can anyone not like Doll House or Tru Calling?
The one part of the book that made me rethink the rating was the ending. I HATE books, movies and TV shows that have that to be continued type of release. The closing, for me, has to be complete in some way. It can be open ended or lead to more to come but there should be some sort of conclusion of the action. In my opinion this book didn't give that to me and it made me upset. Otherwise it was fantastic!
Show More
as possible. Are you confused yet? Leah was too when she found a mark forming on her wrist which she finds out means that she is a part of the prophecy. The Prophecy of the Sisters is very poetic in its style, Zink does an amazing job of using beautiful words to describe every little action of the story. I am sure listening to the audio version of the book something to do with my opinion. The book was read by actress Eliza Dushku and she did a great job but at first it was weird trying to get her face and the characters she plays on TV out of my head. I am a huge fan of hers. Can anyone not like Doll House or Tru Calling?
The one part of the book that made me rethink the rating was the ending. I HATE books, movies and TV shows that have that to be continued type of release. The closing, for me, has to be complete in some way. It can be open ended or lead to more to come but there should be some sort of conclusion of the action. In my opinion this book didn't give that to me and it made me upset. Otherwise it was fantastic!
Show Less
LibraryThing member bookwormygirl
Sixteen-year-old Amalia Milthorpe and her twin sister Alice have just become orphans, and, as Lia discovers, they have also become enemies. The twins are part of an ancient prophecy that has turned generations of sisters against each other. To escape from a dark fate and to remain in the arms of
Talk about sibling rivalry - and although these sisters are on opposing sides of the prophecy, I loved how neither is wholly good nor bad. I love that Ms. Zink’s story has such strong female characters. They embody the best and worst in us all. Lia is on a journey of discovery, love, loss, and what it means to grow up. I love the way that the “twin” thing is played out - neither girl knows what the other is thinking, they only think they know. But I know, right? Or do I? Accckkk.
I loved the Victorian backdrop - with the obligatory rainy nights, howling winds, the swishing of heavy dresses, the rushing waters and high cliff tops, but it's done so perfectly that every little detail contributes to, but doesn't override, each scene.
The story is riddled with symbolism both subtle and dark. Every time I thought I had finally unlocked the mystery, I was taken on a new unexpected turn that left me in awe. The story started a bit slow for me but that was okay because it slowly built up to this fantastically riveting story - and the best part of it all is that it’s the first of a trilogy.
This was a fast, enjoyable read. I highly recommend this to both teens and adults alike. I can't wait for the next one!
Show More
her beloved boyfriend James, Lia must end the prophecy before her sister does. Only then will she understand the mysterious circumstances of her parents' deaths, the true meaning of the strange mark branded on her wrist, and the lengths to which her sister will go to defeat her.Talk about sibling rivalry - and although these sisters are on opposing sides of the prophecy, I loved how neither is wholly good nor bad. I love that Ms. Zink’s story has such strong female characters. They embody the best and worst in us all. Lia is on a journey of discovery, love, loss, and what it means to grow up. I love the way that the “twin” thing is played out - neither girl knows what the other is thinking, they only think they know. But I know, right? Or do I? Accckkk.
I loved the Victorian backdrop - with the obligatory rainy nights, howling winds, the swishing of heavy dresses, the rushing waters and high cliff tops, but it's done so perfectly that every little detail contributes to, but doesn't override, each scene.
The story is riddled with symbolism both subtle and dark. Every time I thought I had finally unlocked the mystery, I was taken on a new unexpected turn that left me in awe. The story started a bit slow for me but that was okay because it slowly built up to this fantastically riveting story - and the best part of it all is that it’s the first of a trilogy.
This was a fast, enjoyable read. I highly recommend this to both teens and adults alike. I can't wait for the next one!
Show Less
LibraryThing member emilove
My Thoughts: (There is a possibility of spoilers, but you should be safe.)
Prophecy of the Sisters is one of the most beautifully written novels I have read of late. There is intrigue and mystery from the very first chapter. This is a book that I read late into the night, every night. The only
When I picked up Zink's book, I was sure it would be a predictable, Victorian era, mystery. I am in no way ashamed to say I was wrong. Even when you think you know what's going to happen, you really don't. This is no typical mystery that Lia and Alice face, this is a quest, one that could save the world, or plunge it into oblivion.
Lia's voice is, honestly, beautiful. You feel as if you are sitting in front of a roaring fire in her Victorian parlor as Lia reads to us the story of her life. I was skeptical when I learned that this was a sister versus sister story, I felt it could go horribly wrong. I had no idea it was possible to convey so easily the hatred that hung in the air between Lia and Alice, and yet still show the deep love that two sisters have for each other. Alice is a superb villain. Michelle writes descriptions so bewitchingly that you can see the emotions in Alice's eyes, on her face, as if she were standing in front of you.
Lia and Alice's world is described so perfectly, yet the detail doesn't go overboard. You know exactly what the characters are seeing, yet do not get bombarded by every nook and cranny in their home of Birchwood.
There is something happening in every chapter, never a dull moment. The ending is an example of the perfect cliffhanger.
If I had to pick one word to describe this book it would be: vivid.
I eagerly await the sequel.
The Verdict: I don't care what your genre is, you must read Prophecy of the Sisters.
Prophecy of the Sisters is one of the most beautifully written novels I have read of late. There is intrigue and mystery from the very first chapter. This is a book that I read late into the night, every night. The only
Show More
thing that stopped me from going forward was actually falling asleep, book still in hand, at 3 am.When I picked up Zink's book, I was sure it would be a predictable, Victorian era, mystery. I am in no way ashamed to say I was wrong. Even when you think you know what's going to happen, you really don't. This is no typical mystery that Lia and Alice face, this is a quest, one that could save the world, or plunge it into oblivion.
Lia's voice is, honestly, beautiful. You feel as if you are sitting in front of a roaring fire in her Victorian parlor as Lia reads to us the story of her life. I was skeptical when I learned that this was a sister versus sister story, I felt it could go horribly wrong. I had no idea it was possible to convey so easily the hatred that hung in the air between Lia and Alice, and yet still show the deep love that two sisters have for each other. Alice is a superb villain. Michelle writes descriptions so bewitchingly that you can see the emotions in Alice's eyes, on her face, as if she were standing in front of you.
Lia and Alice's world is described so perfectly, yet the detail doesn't go overboard. You know exactly what the characters are seeing, yet do not get bombarded by every nook and cranny in their home of Birchwood.
There is something happening in every chapter, never a dull moment. The ending is an example of the perfect cliffhanger.
If I had to pick one word to describe this book it would be: vivid.
I eagerly await the sequel.
The Verdict: I don't care what your genre is, you must read Prophecy of the Sisters.
Show Less
LibraryThing member bsafarik
This book kept me reading. It throws mystery after mystery, giving a few clues along the way so that the reader may attempt to play a role in the solutions being sought after. My only disappointment is that it is the first of a new series, and it is the only one that has been published (2009)! So
Show More
once you're done with this "episode", prepare for a little wait for the next edition and to find out what happens in the further continuation of the battle between good and evil! Show Less
LibraryThing member MrsBond
I grabbed this book because the cover caught my attention. I didn't realize it was part of a trilogy until there were only a few pages left of the book, and the story felt like it had only just begun. My disappointment is a good thing though, because I didn't want the story to end. This classic
Show More
tale of good versus evil naturally unfolds as the author shows a hidden world. While this part of the tale takes place in the US, it feels like England. Looking forward to book 2. Sidenote: Could not help but envision SecondLife during the flying scenes. Show Less
LibraryThing member SueRidnour
Zink’s debut novel is a good old-fashioned gothic horror-romance set in late nineteenth-century New York. The death of 16-year-old twin sisters Lia and Alice Milthorpe's father sets in motion a strange series of events. Lia, the narrator, discovers a mythical mark branded on her wrist and suffers
Show More
terrifying dreams. The twins, never close to begin with, learn that they are cursed by an ancient prophecy which destroyed their parents and will divide them in a battle between good and evil. With intricate plot twists, complex characters, and lyrical prose, this book will be enjoyed on its own merits, but fans will be delighted to discover the ending leaves room for a sequel. Show Less
LibraryThing member epbee
I may be bias on this one, as anything that is a Gothic style Historical Fiction with supernatural elements is automatically a "Melissa" book," Michelle Zink mixed magic, mystery and mythology to craft this wonderful new addition to the Paranormal YA Genre. I have read below where some have labeled
Show More
this book as slow moving, does that have to be a bad thing? I personally loved the sense of foreboding and suspense that was built throughout the book, and, as this clearly will not be stand-alone book, why rush things? This first book focused mostly on the puzzle that is the Prophecy, readers being introduced to, and learning more about it as Lia, the main character does as well. I enjoy trying to work out puzzles and reading about complex and well thought out mythologies, so it didn't bother me that there wasn't a monster attacking on every other page. This book is very deliberate on revealing its secrets in a balanced way. Even on the last few places we are still gathering more information and tucking it away for the next book. The Mystery does not simply revolve around the mythology though; there are also wonderful shades of gray in the relations of the characters, Lia and her twin sister Alice, one sister born to protect and another to destroy. The sisters are not your standard GOOD VS. EVIL however, while Lia is questioning her own role in the prophecy, readers are left to question Alice. Alice as a character is unique, she is written into a position of being the villain, but there seems to be a disconnect between her words and actions at times, and certainly between her given role and desires, giving the reader the sense that things really may not be as they seem, and we will have to keep reading to see where Alice, and even Lia land on the Good vs. Evil scale in the end. The relationship between the two sisters is central to Michelle Zink's entire mythos, and it seems we have only had glimpse of what is to come. I consider this book to be an excellent example of story crafting, with it's focus on exposition, and Lia's own self questioning and discovery, I'm only guessing, but I think, as Michelle fleshes out her continuing story the focus will move away from information sharing, and more on the relationships in the story, Lia and Alice especially but I also see interesting directions for Lia and her friends, and don't forget there is pretty boy in the mix! If Lia doesn't make it James, I know where you can find someone who loves books as much as you...is 27 too old for you? Show Less
LibraryThing member maidenveil
I love, love, love the way the story was written. The way it unfolded the mystery, the characters introduced, and even the way it ended. I was lucky that I read The Prophecy of the Sisters with Guardian of the Gate at hand or else this book is another addition to those who makes me go mental with
Show More
the wait.There is the stark contrast between Lia and Alice is despite being identical twins. The mood is set in the beginning and if not maintained, goes to set the mood for the sequel, Guardian of the Gate.Though there is the "formal" tone used to match the setting (1800s New York), there is nothing short of fantastic in Michelle Zink's writing. It's enough to transport you back in time and into the supernatural prophecy of the battle between good and evil.This is an absolute must-read that will leave you wanting for the next one as soon as you finish reading! Show Less
LibraryThing member LarissaBookGirl
Lia stands in the rain, she stands in grief, she stands beside her family, but she stands alone. The grave has taken her last parent and now she is truly an orphan, with no one to guide her and no one to turn to.
Lia stands on Alice's right as she always has, but she will no longer look on her
A book has been found; The Book of Chaos. It is an ancient book by its look, containing only a single page, written in Latin. Translated it is discovered to be a tale of angels, or demons. A tale of Gates and Guardians, a tale of twins; twins like Lia and Alice.
Lia discovers that her destiny has long been written in a prophecy, the Prophecy Of The Sisters. As evil approaches she must make a choice, but is her choice the right one, and will her choice turn her sister, her best friend, against her forever?
The Prophecy Of The Sisters is a tale of two sisters, twins, who are as dissimilar in mind as they are similar in looks. A dark world of destiny, duty and demons sets the backdrop for this dangerous tale of loss and possibilities. A tale in which an angel is charged to lead the demons of hell to bring about the end of the world.
Lia stands on Alice's right as she always has, but she will no longer look on her
Show More
sister as she once did, and she will no longer stand beside her sister as she once had. Lia is changed, marked, and she learns no one is as they seem; including herself.A book has been found; The Book of Chaos. It is an ancient book by its look, containing only a single page, written in Latin. Translated it is discovered to be a tale of angels, or demons. A tale of Gates and Guardians, a tale of twins; twins like Lia and Alice.
Lia discovers that her destiny has long been written in a prophecy, the Prophecy Of The Sisters. As evil approaches she must make a choice, but is her choice the right one, and will her choice turn her sister, her best friend, against her forever?
The Prophecy Of The Sisters is a tale of two sisters, twins, who are as dissimilar in mind as they are similar in looks. A dark world of destiny, duty and demons sets the backdrop for this dangerous tale of loss and possibilities. A tale in which an angel is charged to lead the demons of hell to bring about the end of the world.
Show Less
LibraryThing member CatholicKittie
I had heard a lot of things about this novel; both good and bad things. One of my favorite ones was a bad one because I was inclined to agree, but where they hated it because of one thing; I liked it for that one reason.
This reviewer said that nothing ever happened it was just talking at various
I didn't think I was going to like this story much because I hate when families are pitted against one another because I always feel it is unrealistic. If my sister was an evil witch than I still wouldn't go against her, we are family I don't give a crap how bad she was. But I did not have that problem with it in this story; I actually thought Lea was too soft on Alice! I can't give it away but you will know what I am talking about when you read it. I thought Lea should be doing some slapping! I can understand Michelle Zink not wanting to say "So I bitch slapped that wicked witch!" It is YA but she could have used a more tame description like "I molly-whopped Alice for what she did. She was evil for real yo!" I am joking but Lea's reactions were far too weak and soft. That is my only complaint with this book. Also it felt like it didn't resolve any issue. The end was anti-climatic. I always think a series/trilogy should have a "grand theme" that runs unresolved through to the end, the big finale, so to speak and a mini-plot that can be concluded at the end of the current book. Each installment with it's own mini-theme that can be resolved. This series does not have that. Still a good read.
This reviewer said that nothing ever happened it was just talking at various
Show More
locations. And though that is pretty much the case, liked that about this book. I liked that Michelle Zink didn't feel the need to stuff it full with so much action that we never really caught the information being revealed. Zink did a lot of research for this book and it is evident. Those of you, who aren't angel-junkies like me, may think that it is majorly fictionalized to fit the story but it is not. This makes Zink's novel all the more amazing. She found a way to tell the story built around something that already exists so it almost feels organic and real.I didn't think I was going to like this story much because I hate when families are pitted against one another because I always feel it is unrealistic. If my sister was an evil witch than I still wouldn't go against her, we are family I don't give a crap how bad she was. But I did not have that problem with it in this story; I actually thought Lea was too soft on Alice! I can't give it away but you will know what I am talking about when you read it. I thought Lea should be doing some slapping! I can understand Michelle Zink not wanting to say "So I bitch slapped that wicked witch!" It is YA but she could have used a more tame description like "I molly-whopped Alice for what she did. She was evil for real yo!" I am joking but Lea's reactions were far too weak and soft. That is my only complaint with this book. Also it felt like it didn't resolve any issue. The end was anti-climatic. I always think a series/trilogy should have a "grand theme" that runs unresolved through to the end, the big finale, so to speak and a mini-plot that can be concluded at the end of the current book. Each installment with it's own mini-theme that can be resolved. This series does not have that. Still a good read.
Show Less
LibraryThing member cinnleigh
PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS really has two major players in the story. Alice and Lia are twin sisters living in the times of corset and petticoats. Lia, from whose point-of-view the story is told, is the more awkward of the sisters but has a kind heart and a gentle soul. Her sister, on the other hand,
Since childhood, James has owned Lia's heart. A charming young man who works with his father in the family bookstore, James makes frequent trips to Lia’s home to catalogue her father’s expansive book collection. A happy side effect of these trips is the time that James and Lia get to spend together. Whether it’s secret visits to cuddle under their favorite tree or a stroll along the water, these two lovebirds seem to have a fairly strong bond. When the darkness starts to encroach on the light, however, it will be a challenge to see if the strength of their love can keep the two together.
The Prophecy of the Sisters is an ancient tale, often thought of as myth, of two sisters destined to serve as the line between good and evil. At first Lia doesn’t want to believe to the story; in the prophecy, one sister shall act as the guardian of peace while the other acts as the gateway to the Apocalypse. When Lia discovers a strange mark bloom on her skin shortly after her father’s death, she’ll be led on a journey of discovery. With this prophecy potentially at play, she may not like what she discovers.
I absolutely loved PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS. In my opinion, Ms. Zink did an amazing job taking an old myth and giving it her own special twist to create this compelling story. If it makes any sense, part of what made this book so great was the simplicity of the story while keeping the complexity of the layers at the same time. With the multiple twists and turns throughout the story, I expected to get bogged down at some point, but Ms. Zink’s writing remained very fluid and easy to follow. Even though there was quite a bit of devious scheming and some side story, this maintained a natural progression. Meanwhile, Ms. Zink instilled quite a bit of elaboration within the story. Twists and turns combined with quite a few unexpected events made for a story that was unpredictable yet comfortable.
The other part of this book that made it a winner to me is the romance within the story. As we proceed through the story we learn more about the love between James and Lia. There is definitely a tender feel to the characters; at the same time there is also something you can’t quite put your finger on. There is something different in the relationship that will be exciting to explore in Ms. Zink’s future books.
Admittedly, I am an easily spooked person. When I first started reading PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS I did so in bed, in the middle of the night by myself. I would probably not recommend that. Once I really understood where the story was going, a little of the spook factor went away, but overall there is definitely a creepy aspect to the book. Between the voices whispering in the dark and the midnight rituals, this story really got the hairs on the back of my neck hopping up. The best way to describe this book is dark and deliciously addictive. I read this story in a day and now am excited to see what else Ms. Zink has up her sleeves.
Show More
exudes confidence and ambition. If the clash in personalities wasn’t enough to separate these two sisters, the recent death of their father brings to light a truth that could put the girls on opposite sides of an age-old battle.Since childhood, James has owned Lia's heart. A charming young man who works with his father in the family bookstore, James makes frequent trips to Lia’s home to catalogue her father’s expansive book collection. A happy side effect of these trips is the time that James and Lia get to spend together. Whether it’s secret visits to cuddle under their favorite tree or a stroll along the water, these two lovebirds seem to have a fairly strong bond. When the darkness starts to encroach on the light, however, it will be a challenge to see if the strength of their love can keep the two together.
The Prophecy of the Sisters is an ancient tale, often thought of as myth, of two sisters destined to serve as the line between good and evil. At first Lia doesn’t want to believe to the story; in the prophecy, one sister shall act as the guardian of peace while the other acts as the gateway to the Apocalypse. When Lia discovers a strange mark bloom on her skin shortly after her father’s death, she’ll be led on a journey of discovery. With this prophecy potentially at play, she may not like what she discovers.
I absolutely loved PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS. In my opinion, Ms. Zink did an amazing job taking an old myth and giving it her own special twist to create this compelling story. If it makes any sense, part of what made this book so great was the simplicity of the story while keeping the complexity of the layers at the same time. With the multiple twists and turns throughout the story, I expected to get bogged down at some point, but Ms. Zink’s writing remained very fluid and easy to follow. Even though there was quite a bit of devious scheming and some side story, this maintained a natural progression. Meanwhile, Ms. Zink instilled quite a bit of elaboration within the story. Twists and turns combined with quite a few unexpected events made for a story that was unpredictable yet comfortable.
The other part of this book that made it a winner to me is the romance within the story. As we proceed through the story we learn more about the love between James and Lia. There is definitely a tender feel to the characters; at the same time there is also something you can’t quite put your finger on. There is something different in the relationship that will be exciting to explore in Ms. Zink’s future books.
Admittedly, I am an easily spooked person. When I first started reading PROPHECY OF THE SISTERS I did so in bed, in the middle of the night by myself. I would probably not recommend that. Once I really understood where the story was going, a little of the spook factor went away, but overall there is definitely a creepy aspect to the book. Between the voices whispering in the dark and the midnight rituals, this story really got the hairs on the back of my neck hopping up. The best way to describe this book is dark and deliciously addictive. I read this story in a day and now am excited to see what else Ms. Zink has up her sleeves.
Show Less
LibraryThing member taramatchi
I was not sure what I would think at first, but by the middle I was hooked into this story. I loved the fight between good and evil that ensues after the prophecy is revealed. It kind of felt like a guilty pleasure to read, and I needed a little break from the heavier material that I have been
It was probably more of a 3 star book for me, but since I was so engrossed in the story at the end...I bumped it up a star. Sometimes I just feel like giving a star for the entertainment factor.
It fits nicely into the fantasy genre, and so if that jump from reality is not your thing you may want to skip this one. I felt there were parts where I needed to make that jump or I may have found it a bit cheesy.
The only thing that annoyed me was that sometimes it was a bit much when it came to the main character's thoughts and inner dialogue with herself, I thought at times it bordered on the obvious. How many times can she question her thoughts about telling her boyfriend about the prophecy and tell me her obvious reasons.
Overall, I did enjoy it and hope to read the next book in the series when it comes out this summer. I think that this series would make nice summer reads or as a guilty pleasure.
Show More
reading. It was probably more of a 3 star book for me, but since I was so engrossed in the story at the end...I bumped it up a star. Sometimes I just feel like giving a star for the entertainment factor.
It fits nicely into the fantasy genre, and so if that jump from reality is not your thing you may want to skip this one. I felt there were parts where I needed to make that jump or I may have found it a bit cheesy.
The only thing that annoyed me was that sometimes it was a bit much when it came to the main character's thoughts and inner dialogue with herself, I thought at times it bordered on the obvious. How many times can she question her thoughts about telling her boyfriend about the prophecy and tell me her obvious reasons.
Overall, I did enjoy it and hope to read the next book in the series when it comes out this summer. I think that this series would make nice summer reads or as a guilty pleasure.
Show Less
LibraryThing member marcejewels
Prophecy Sisters reminded me of the show Charmed which I am a huge fan plus thriller and suspense is my favourite genre to read, so you guessed it I loved this story. The research of a prophecy, sibling rivalry, family history with drama and a love romance that was a secret to all….
Prophecy
I want to share this passage with you, it is not a spoiler for the book. I had it bookmarked and constantly went back to it while reading. This definitely is a book to buy not to read on an ereader. Found in an old book and Lia’s boyfriend translated it for her.
Through fire and harmony mankind endured
Until the sending of
the Guards
Who took as wives and lovers the woman of
man,
Engendering His wrath.
Two sisters, formed in the same swaying
ocean,
One Guardian, One the Gate.
One keeper of peace,
The other
batering sorcery for devotion.
Cast from the heavens, the Souls were
Lost
As the Sisters continue the battle
Until the Gates summon
forth their return,
Or the Angel brings the Keys to the Abyss.
The
Army, marching forth through the Gates.
Samael, the Beast, through the
Angel.
The Angel, guarded only by the gossamer veil of protection.
Four
Marks, Four Keys, Circle of Fire
Birthed in the first breath of Samhain
In
the shadow of the Mystic Stone Serpent of Aubur.
Let the Angel's Gate swing
without the Keys
Followed by the Seven Plagues and No
Return.
Death
Famine
Blood
Fire
Darkness
Drought
Ruin
Open
your arms, Mistress of Chaos, that the havoc of the Beast will flow
like a
river
For all is lost when the Seven Plagues begin.
If this passage intrigues you at all, I recommend you pick this one up and enjoy the mysterious journey.
The two concerns I had that was odd to me was that it was set around the 1800’s, it felt modern to me and every time the period was mentioned I kind of raised my eyebrows but this wasn’t a big deal to me but it may be to others. Also, as much as I enjoyed all of the characters, Michelle Zink did a great job with them. There was a major event that happened near the end and all except Lia didn’t seemed affected, it was just weird.
I thoroughly enjoyed my time reading this one. Sometimes I found myself daydreaming after a chapter and trying to think ahead, twice I even said ‘I knew it”.
Prophecy
Show More
Sisters is a dark mystery, every chapter gave you a little more to the prophecy you are trying to figure out along with the Lia. The more she digs, researches the more the story captures you. The story is told from Lia’s point of view.I want to share this passage with you, it is not a spoiler for the book. I had it bookmarked and constantly went back to it while reading. This definitely is a book to buy not to read on an ereader. Found in an old book and Lia’s boyfriend translated it for her.
Through fire and harmony mankind endured
Until the sending of
the Guards
Who took as wives and lovers the woman of
man,
Engendering His wrath.
Two sisters, formed in the same swaying
ocean,
One Guardian, One the Gate.
One keeper of peace,
The other
batering sorcery for devotion.
Cast from the heavens, the Souls were
Lost
As the Sisters continue the battle
Until the Gates summon
forth their return,
Or the Angel brings the Keys to the Abyss.
The
Army, marching forth through the Gates.
Samael, the Beast, through the
Angel.
The Angel, guarded only by the gossamer veil of protection.
Four
Marks, Four Keys, Circle of Fire
Birthed in the first breath of Samhain
In
the shadow of the Mystic Stone Serpent of Aubur.
Let the Angel's Gate swing
without the Keys
Followed by the Seven Plagues and No
Return.
Death
Famine
Blood
Fire
Darkness
Drought
Ruin
Open
your arms, Mistress of Chaos, that the havoc of the Beast will flow
like a
river
For all is lost when the Seven Plagues begin.
If this passage intrigues you at all, I recommend you pick this one up and enjoy the mysterious journey.
The two concerns I had that was odd to me was that it was set around the 1800’s, it felt modern to me and every time the period was mentioned I kind of raised my eyebrows but this wasn’t a big deal to me but it may be to others. Also, as much as I enjoyed all of the characters, Michelle Zink did a great job with them. There was a major event that happened near the end and all except Lia didn’t seemed affected, it was just weird.
I thoroughly enjoyed my time reading this one. Sometimes I found myself daydreaming after a chapter and trying to think ahead, twice I even said ‘I knew it”.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Ladybug83
My tears have dried and I'm finally able to write a review. I cried through the last 30 pages of the book, and that ladies and gentlemen was not because the book was poorly written. Why I didn't give this book a five star rating? I'm saving it for Guardian of the Gate ;)And so the Prophecy begins
Show More
:"Perhaps because it seems so appropriate, I don't notice the rain. It falls in sheets, a blanket of silvery thread rushing to the hard almost-winter ground. Still, I stand without moving at the side of the coffin."What's the book about?Twin sisters Lia and Alice and their little brother Henry have recently become orphans. The day their father is buried one of the sisters discovers a strange mark on the underside of her wrist. The mark is the beginning to a revelation of a dark prophecy that takes rivalry between sisters to a whole new level(and has done so for ages). The prophecy is old and hard to interpret, it's like a riddle, to understand the meaning of it all help is needed. But where can one turn for help, who to trust?My thoughts on Prophecy of the Sisters:I loved it and cannot wait to get my hands on the next book, Guardian of the Gate! It is hard to believe that Prophecy of the Sisters is Michelle Zink's debut novel. This is a skilfully crafted novel with three dimensional characters. This book was a treat and extremely hard to put down, it might not have been such a good idea to start this book less than a week before my exam.If you read the first paragraph you noticed the gloomy beginning, this novel has a very Gothic feel all the way through. It fits perfect to a story based on a prophecy set in New York in the Victorian era. I could just about feel the rain and the wind seeping off the pages. Zink never bores the reader with tedious descriptions of things and places. See I kind of have an issue with overly detailed descriptions *blush* If there's one thing I might put my finger on it must be the character Henry, I so wish we'd get to know him a bit better, that he was a bigger part of the plot. Perhaps we will see more of him in the future?If the second book, Guardian of the Gate is 10 times better I need to be alone once I get my hands on it. Lock myself up in a room and stay there with my book. Show Less
LibraryThing member book_worm127
This book was a slight disappointment for me. It moved a lot slower than I thought it would, and for some reason I was expecting it to be alternating POV between the two sisters. I think that I probably would have liked it more if it had been, just because it would shake things up a bit. One thing
The writing style that Zink used was engrossing, and I found myself thinking like Lia when I put the book down. There is a sense of mystery throughout the entire book, which kept me reading. As the narrator I liked Lia, she wasn't a push over but knew when to back off.I felt a connection to all of the characters, and when tragedy strikes towards the end of the book I found myself staring at the pages in disbelief, shocked and sad.
I thought that this book was pretty obviously the set up for the next two. We spend a lot of time learning things, not very much actual doing something about them. I think that the next book, Guardian of the Gate will have more doing. If you want a neatly tied up ending, don't come looking here, it leaves you with more questions asked than answered.
Basically this book moved a lot slower than I thought it would, but the rich historical setting and overwhelming sense of mystery kept me reading.
Show More
that I loved was how well the historical elements were used. Zink really did her research, and I loved how detailed everything was without her describing every little thing. The writing style that Zink used was engrossing, and I found myself thinking like Lia when I put the book down. There is a sense of mystery throughout the entire book, which kept me reading. As the narrator I liked Lia, she wasn't a push over but knew when to back off.I felt a connection to all of the characters, and when tragedy strikes towards the end of the book I found myself staring at the pages in disbelief, shocked and sad.
I thought that this book was pretty obviously the set up for the next two. We spend a lot of time learning things, not very much actual doing something about them. I think that the next book, Guardian of the Gate will have more doing. If you want a neatly tied up ending, don't come looking here, it leaves you with more questions asked than answered.
Basically this book moved a lot slower than I thought it would, but the rich historical setting and overwhelming sense of mystery kept me reading.
Show Less
LibraryThing member monsterofbooks
I really don't know how to go about this review. A part of me enjoyed it and the other half didn't. It was an ok book for me and I think three stars represent that. I certainly will read the sequel.
I love reading books with the settings that are placed 100 to 1000 years ago. This novel is placed in
I commend Michelle Zink for writing so beautifully and portraying first person so passionately. I really felt that she had a firm grasp on first person and how to write it. What I did not like was the book felt to outlined. It was so plotted, that the novel became obvious and had no surprise effect on me.
The novel was rather slow and nothing really happened, or no action anyways. The end was a bit interesting because the antagonist is so ruthless that it kills someone close to them. And I was quite sadden by that character's demise, because that person didn't deserve it at all. But the aftermath was weird, because the antagonist is never brought to justice or arrested.
One other thing that I wish this novel had was more Alice. Alice is such a key part of the prophecy, but you see so little of her throughout the novel.
In character terms, I enjoyed reading from Lia's perspective. She was by far my favorite character, next to Alice. I felt because Lia and Alice were such an important part of the story, that they had more depth and personality then the other characters did which was fine but I'd like to learn more about Sonia and Luisa next time.
Overall Prophecy of the Sisters was a nice read and was well written. I will definitely keep my eyes open for the sequel, Guardian of the Gate.
I love reading books with the settings that are placed 100 to 1000 years ago. This novel is placed in
Show More
the late 1800's in America, which to me is very uncommon. Usually I see books with that time period set in Europe. So I did welcome the nice change of setting, but throughout the book I had to remind myself that this wasn't a Hallowmere or Gemma Doyle type book because if gave off the same sort of vibe.I commend Michelle Zink for writing so beautifully and portraying first person so passionately. I really felt that she had a firm grasp on first person and how to write it. What I did not like was the book felt to outlined. It was so plotted, that the novel became obvious and had no surprise effect on me.
The novel was rather slow and nothing really happened, or no action anyways. The end was a bit interesting because the antagonist is so ruthless that it kills someone close to them. And I was quite sadden by that character's demise, because that person didn't deserve it at all. But the aftermath was weird, because the antagonist is never brought to justice or arrested.
One other thing that I wish this novel had was more Alice. Alice is such a key part of the prophecy, but you see so little of her throughout the novel.
In character terms, I enjoyed reading from Lia's perspective. She was by far my favorite character, next to Alice. I felt because Lia and Alice were such an important part of the story, that they had more depth and personality then the other characters did which was fine but I'd like to learn more about Sonia and Luisa next time.
Overall Prophecy of the Sisters was a nice read and was well written. I will definitely keep my eyes open for the sequel, Guardian of the Gate.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Awesomeness1
Lia and Alice Milthorpe are twin sisters that just became orphans. Their father has died a mysterious death, just as their mother did many years earlier. Following this tragic incident, Lia finds a tattoo-like mark on her wrist, her first clue that she is entangled in a mysterious prophecy that has
You know that quote "the opposite of love is not hate; it's indifference"? Well, that's how I feel about this book. I just didn't care about it at all. The book wasn't bad. When a book is bad, it works up negative feelings for me, and I end up with a ranting review of several pages. This book, however, was "meh" to the extreme.
Everything was dry, lifeless as a limp noodle. I could tell it wanted to be a gothic, A Great and Terrible Beauty-like tale, but it wasn't. Not in the least. There was no drama or tone or action. Lia had no personality and her narrtive consisted of telling rather than showing. All the characters did was sit and talk, walk and talk, ride horses and talk.
Alice was supposed to be a big bad sister that Lia was once close to, but I didn't get that impression. Alice and Lia were already distant by the beginning of the book, and perhaps if Zink had started out with them close, that would have created more tension.
There is also a love interest that doesn't even deserve mentioning.
And the Prophecy was all too easy to figure out. I was ages ahead of the characters and felt like a girlfriend tapping her foot, waiting for her boyfriend to catch up with her at the mall. There were several "surprises", but I wasn't particularly surprised.
I rarely don't finish a book. I believe in giving a book a chance. Well, I got to page 250 of this novel, and I couldn't care less about the ending. Huh. You know a book is flat when I say "couldn't care less". I hate that expression. There was this girl in middle school who said that about everything and I just wanted to punch her in the face. Anyway......
This book is a definite miss for me, which is kind of disappointing. The premise seemed intriguing, but as I didn't even finish the book, I doubt I will be reading the sequel. I am still astounded as to how people gave this book such good reviews. How did I miss that spark? Alas, my favorite thing about this book remains the cover.
Show More
a history of turning sisters against each other. Lia finds herself doubting whom to trust and what her role in the events shall be. You know that quote "the opposite of love is not hate; it's indifference"? Well, that's how I feel about this book. I just didn't care about it at all. The book wasn't bad. When a book is bad, it works up negative feelings for me, and I end up with a ranting review of several pages. This book, however, was "meh" to the extreme.
Everything was dry, lifeless as a limp noodle. I could tell it wanted to be a gothic, A Great and Terrible Beauty-like tale, but it wasn't. Not in the least. There was no drama or tone or action. Lia had no personality and her narrtive consisted of telling rather than showing. All the characters did was sit and talk, walk and talk, ride horses and talk.
Alice was supposed to be a big bad sister that Lia was once close to, but I didn't get that impression. Alice and Lia were already distant by the beginning of the book, and perhaps if Zink had started out with them close, that would have created more tension.
There is also a love interest that doesn't even deserve mentioning.
And the Prophecy was all too easy to figure out. I was ages ahead of the characters and felt like a girlfriend tapping her foot, waiting for her boyfriend to catch up with her at the mall. There were several "surprises", but I wasn't particularly surprised.
I rarely don't finish a book. I believe in giving a book a chance. Well, I got to page 250 of this novel, and I couldn't care less about the ending. Huh. You know a book is flat when I say "couldn't care less". I hate that expression. There was this girl in middle school who said that about everything and I just wanted to punch her in the face. Anyway......
This book is a definite miss for me, which is kind of disappointing. The premise seemed intriguing, but as I didn't even finish the book, I doubt I will be reading the sequel. I am still astounded as to how people gave this book such good reviews. How did I miss that spark? Alas, my favorite thing about this book remains the cover.
Show Less
LibraryThing member PattyLouise
The premise of this book is that within the history of our world there have always been Guardians and Gates. One is good and one is not so good. The Guardian and Gate have always been sisters and the role each sister plays is determined by birth order. There is a lot of mystery within this story.
I love the era of this book. Horse drawn carriages and lamps that have to be lit by hand and servants and long dresses and chaperones. Tea in the drawing room…pens that must be dipped into ink…no IPADS or KINDLES anywhere. I thought the story was beautifully written and quite captivating. Characters were beautifully portrayed from Aunt Virginia to Henry to Edmond the driver…each character had a well explained personality. I must say that I read the book quickly. This was because there were so many exciting parts I had to know what happened next. There is a Book 2 which I will be reading shortly.
Show More
People have died and have left incomplete messages and tasks that need to be deciphered and completed or literally all hell will break loose. There are tons of souls dying to get back to the living world. There is one fierce soul determined to break through the gate and rule the world…Samael… he must be stopped. Alice and Lia are the sisters who play the key roles in this story. In the beginning of the novel the roles of the sisters were unclear but as the story progresses the plight of one sister is key to the unfolding of the story. Finding others who are destined to help her is tantamount to saving life as we know it. One sister is true and honest and will put the safety of others first. The other sister is determined to open the Gate and let Samael wreak havoc on the Earth that we know. I love the era of this book. Horse drawn carriages and lamps that have to be lit by hand and servants and long dresses and chaperones. Tea in the drawing room…pens that must be dipped into ink…no IPADS or KINDLES anywhere. I thought the story was beautifully written and quite captivating. Characters were beautifully portrayed from Aunt Virginia to Henry to Edmond the driver…each character had a well explained personality. I must say that I read the book quickly. This was because there were so many exciting parts I had to know what happened next. There is a Book 2 which I will be reading shortly.
Show Less
LibraryThing member pocketmermaid
This book had a lot of potential. At least that's what I convinced myself when I picked it up off the audio shelf at the library. Interesting title, evocative cover, and intriguing flap copy ... I thought I'd be thrilled with this find. I love slightly spooky, fantastical plots rich in myth and
However, all that potential was wasted on this sluggish story; it never actually went anywhere. No, really, it never went anywhere - this book didn't have an ending. It only resulted a cliffhanger after an unusually long build-up that served only to set up a sequel. Had I known this going in, I would not have bothered. I feel that a book that's part of a series should work alone as well as being part of a unit. This just felt unfinished and, therefore, completely unsatisfying.
Lia's narration was repetitive (a handful of overused words annoyed the crap out of me), and she was uninteresting. Her boringness made the story elements hard to swallow. Her twin sister, Alice, the "bad" one was only slightly more interesting. But Alice never actually felt threatening enough to be a true villain.
The love story was stilted. We are plopped into a post-courtship relationship of Lia and James, and I didn't give a fig about them. I personally like reading about the emotions of the beginning of a relationship (or the end). It makes me feel connected to the characters and interested in the couple. I thought James was okay for Lia, but I barely got to know him. He had so little screen time that I wondered why Lia's character even needed a boyfriend at all if he wasn't going to be utilized for any story-related reason that I could discern. Characters should not be used as props.
At least he wasn't the only one. Lia's classmates Luisa and Sonia were lacking so much in the personality department that I couldn't tell either one of them apart - except that one of them was from Italy and the other from England. I suppose that character birthplace meant to be interesting or relevant somehow.
These characters do more talking than taking any action. They attempt to explain and figure out things with conversation instead of going out and doing something. The reader is simply told the things he or she is meant to understand. And little time was spent on getting the reader to understand the plot.
Oh yeah -- let's talk about plot. An afterthought in my review, just as it felt an afterthought in the book. It all seemed a little murky and I don't feel as if I know enough about it to discuss it at any great length. There's an ancient prophecy, see, involving twin sisters every generation . . . and then something about the end of the world. Lia seemed to get it, though, for the most part. That's good. If she got it, then I guess I don't really need to understand, even if I do feel a little left out.
Though there are a couple of great things here, I'm not gonna lie. It did earn two whole stars fro me, after all. The setting of Victorian New York is absolutely vivid. I could envision everything that was described to me - the family home, the surrounding land and nearby lake, the town, the school, that gorgeous library - though setting alone isn't enough to shoulder the many needs of a novel.
In the end, what could have been a fantastic book became a disappointment. If you like Victorian fantasy and don't mind being strung along, maybe you won't be as let down by this book like I was. Lia will be meandering through her next installment without the audience of this reader.
Show More
folktales.However, all that potential was wasted on this sluggish story; it never actually went anywhere. No, really, it never went anywhere - this book didn't have an ending. It only resulted a cliffhanger after an unusually long build-up that served only to set up a sequel. Had I known this going in, I would not have bothered. I feel that a book that's part of a series should work alone as well as being part of a unit. This just felt unfinished and, therefore, completely unsatisfying.
Lia's narration was repetitive (a handful of overused words annoyed the crap out of me), and she was uninteresting. Her boringness made the story elements hard to swallow. Her twin sister, Alice, the "bad" one was only slightly more interesting. But Alice never actually felt threatening enough to be a true villain.
The love story was stilted. We are plopped into a post-courtship relationship of Lia and James, and I didn't give a fig about them. I personally like reading about the emotions of the beginning of a relationship (or the end). It makes me feel connected to the characters and interested in the couple. I thought James was okay for Lia, but I barely got to know him. He had so little screen time that I wondered why Lia's character even needed a boyfriend at all if he wasn't going to be utilized for any story-related reason that I could discern. Characters should not be used as props.
At least he wasn't the only one. Lia's classmates Luisa and Sonia were lacking so much in the personality department that I couldn't tell either one of them apart - except that one of them was from Italy and the other from England. I suppose that character birthplace meant to be interesting or relevant somehow.
These characters do more talking than taking any action. They attempt to explain and figure out things with conversation instead of going out and doing something. The reader is simply told the things he or she is meant to understand. And little time was spent on getting the reader to understand the plot.
Oh yeah -- let's talk about plot. An afterthought in my review, just as it felt an afterthought in the book. It all seemed a little murky and I don't feel as if I know enough about it to discuss it at any great length. There's an ancient prophecy, see, involving twin sisters every generation . . . and then something about the end of the world. Lia seemed to get it, though, for the most part. That's good. If she got it, then I guess I don't really need to understand, even if I do feel a little left out.
Though there are a couple of great things here, I'm not gonna lie. It did earn two whole stars fro me, after all. The setting of Victorian New York is absolutely vivid. I could envision everything that was described to me - the family home, the surrounding land and nearby lake, the town, the school, that gorgeous library - though setting alone isn't enough to shoulder the many needs of a novel.
In the end, what could have been a fantastic book became a disappointment. If you like Victorian fantasy and don't mind being strung along, maybe you won't be as let down by this book like I was. Lia will be meandering through her next installment without the audience of this reader.
Show Less
Awards
Chicago Public Library Best of the Best: Teens (Fiction — 2009)
Texas Lone Star Reading List (2010)
Original publication date
2009-08-01
Physical description
352 p.; 5.87 inches
ISBN
0316027421 / 9780316027427
Similar in this library
Need by Carrie Jones
Wake by Lisa McMann