Status
Call number
Genres
Collection
Publication
Description
Young Adult Fiction. Young Adult Literature. HTML: Josh Mendel has a secret. Unfortunately, everyone knows what it is. Five years ago, Josh's life changed. Drastically. And everyone in his school, his town�seems like the world�thinks they understand. But they don't�they can't. And now, about to graduate from high school, Josh is still trying to sort through the pieces. First there's Rachel, the girl he thought he'd lost years ago. She's back, and she's determined to be part of his life, whether he wants her there or not.Then there are college decisions to make, and the toughest baseball game of his life coming up, and a coach who won't stop pushing Josh all the way to the brink. And then there's Eve. Her return brings with it all the memories of Josh's past. It's time for Josh to face the truth about what happened. If only he knew what the truth was . . ..… (more)
User reviews
There have been a number of highly publicized incidents involving minors and school staff. People may be prone to dismiss such occurrences because the perpetrator is a pretty female and they take a "boy's will be boy's" attitude. This book exemplifies the real damage that occurs to the child's psyche as a result of such abuse. I highly recommend reading it.
Because of the abuse, Josh made a mistake with one of his friends. Rachel liked him, but he didn't know how to deal with it and an innocent game of Seven Minutes in Heaven (well, somewhat innocent anyway) ended disastrously. Rachel hasn't spoken to him in 5 years. Math, baseball, and his best friend Zik (who has never, ever asked him about what happened with Mrs. Sherman) are the things that get him through the day. Then Josh accidentally runs into Rachel one night and they start talking again. Josh begins to tell her his story. The whole story. The story he never told anyone except the police.
It's a roller coaster of emotions and even though Josh's story was truly disturbing, I couldn't put it down. I had to get to the end so I could see if he survived, if he could overcome what happened to him. This book is not for everyone. Graphic sexual situations between a teacher and her student will be hard to take for some. But it's a very powerful story. I was rooting for Josh the whole way through.
This is a book of extremely powerful moments, that make the entire book seem better than it actually is. The flashback scenes, in which Josh describes his relationship with Eve, are the most arresting, as the reader understands the situation in ways that Josh cannot. The scenes after the relationship is discovered, in particular, are very vivid. The part of the book set in the present is much weaker, as Lyga can't seem to decide what he wants us to thinkg. Josh is not particuarly likeable or sympathetic, and in some ways that works to the book's advantage, as it throws the reader off kilter. On the other hand, it does make you sympathise with those who dislike him. Josh's obsession with baseball statistics fell flat for me, as I don't know enough about baseball to have them inform the text, nor do I care enough to find out.
The ending of this book was a little to pat, a little to perfect. Much has been made about the sex scenes in this book, which I will say, strayed too far into bodice-ripper territory for me.
Even reading with an adult's eye, I felt my opinions also change as Josh reevaluated his views on love, family, and friendship.
I'd give this to older teens interested in realistic fiction.
And it fascinates me. Not to diminish anyone who was in this situation but, as far as the "dominant, aggressive, older male with younger female" relationship goes in writing, it's been done to death. "Dominant, aggressive older female, younger male" is not. Especially with stories like Mary Kay Letourneau, Debra Lafave, and Pamela Rogers Turner. It follows the mental state of the boy nicely, as he struggles for normalcy in his current relationships, and how his past troubles color him. But he's really coloring himself.
Once again Lyga knocks it out of the park (baseball!). I haven't read a book of his yet that I didn't like profusely. I got exactly what I wanted -- an answer to the question of how a boy gets in a sexual relationship with a teacher. The only thing I wish was that we got a little more insight into the teacher. We never really learn her deal. Was she abused? Was she just unhappy? What was her motivation in starting this relationship? She makes a confession, so there has to be something in there. Maybe this is like real life, where the state keeps the victim and victimizer in the dark about each other's state. And that is the scariest part.
Twelve-year old Josh Mendel has a crush on his history teacher, Eve. When she starts paying him particular attention, he eats it up. What he fails to understand is that Eve is manipulating him
Author Barry Lyga tackles a topic that is usually sugarcoated as a young boy initiated into the wonders of sex by an older, more experienced woman. Lyga addresses the power imbalance and abuse inherent in this type of relationship. While Josh may be ignorant of Eve’s deliberate designs, the reader is not. Lyga deftly rolls out the story of Josh’s becoming entangled in his own confusing, conflicting emotions until he believes he is the one who brings about Eve’s downfall and arrest.
Lyga alternates between twelve-year old and eighteen-year old Josh – during and after the abuse. When older Josh learns that Eve is to be released from prison for good behavior, he struggles to comprehend the guilt and shame he has carried around for so long. While his parents and his friend Rachel are concerned about how Eve’s release might be traumatizing for him, Josh isn’t even sure what his reaction is.
Lyga does not shy away from the graphic reality of the abuse. He captures beautifully the conflict Josh is desperate to untangle, and while Eve’s honesty at the end of the novel helps to bring the story to a close, life may not be quite this neat. Still, this is a small complaint amidst a powerful novel.
Twelve-year old Josh Mendel has a crush on his history teacher, Eve. When she starts paying him particular attention, he eats it up. What he fails to understand is that Eve is manipulating him
Author Barry Lyga tackles a topic that is usually sugarcoated as a young boy initiated into the wonders of sex by an older, more experienced woman. Lyga addresses the power imbalance and abuse inherent in this type of relationship. While Josh may be ignorant of Eve’s deliberate designs, the reader is not. Lyga deftly rolls out the story of Josh’s becoming entangled in his own confusing, conflicting emotions until he believes he is the one who brings about Eve’s downfall and arrest.
Lyga alternates between twelve-year old and eighteen-year old Josh – during and after the abuse. When older Josh learns that Eve is to be released from prison for good behavior, he struggles to comprehend the guilt and shame he has carried around for so long. While his parents and his friend Rachel are concerned about how Eve’s release might be traumatizing for him, Josh isn’t even sure what his reaction is.
Lyga does not shy away from the graphic reality of the abuse. He captures beautifully the conflict Josh is desperate to untangle, and while Eve’s honesty at the end of the novel helps to bring the story to a close, life may not be quite this neat. Still, this is a small complaint amidst a powerful novel.
PROS: Lyga writes in such a way that the most shocking parts of the story are incredibly
CONS: As much as I loved the book, I was REALLY annoyed by the prom scene. I just really wish that prom hadn't been an issue at all - I found the whole scene so cliche that I was rolling my eyes while I read. Still, I was able to overlook it.
Definitely recommend!