Status
Call number
Genres
Collection
Publication
Description
Police Detective Pia Kirchhoff is about to leave on her long-delayed honeymoon when she receives a phone call. An elderly woman has been shot and killed while walking her dog. A short while later another murder is committed and the modus operandi is eerily similar - a woman is killed by a bullet that smashes through her kitchen window ... and in both cases the same weapon fired the shot. Two more murders follow in short order. None of the victims had enemies and no one knows why they were singled out. As fear of the Taunus Sniper grows among the local residents, the pressure rises on Detective Kirchhoff. She and her partner, Oliver von Bodenstein, search for a suspect who appears to murder at will, but as the investigation progresses, the police officers uncover a human tragedy. I am Your Judge is tightly plotted, and delivers surprise twists at every turn with a story that is ripped from the headlines.… (more)
User reviews
This book has an extremely complex plot and readers unfamiliar with the intricacies of German names might have a problem with a slowing down of the suspense. The discussion of the evidence goes on a bit repetitively too. The translated series has been published out of order but I didn't feel like it was detrimental to the story line. I would still recommend reading one of the earlier books to familiarize yourself with the characters since most of them appear in all of the books. If you like your mystery novels deep and complex, you will absolutely enjoy I Am Your Judge.
I enjoyed it for the most part, although there were far too many doctors with varying roles for me to keep them apart in my mind. It went on too long as well and the body count was pretty high. The ending was (despite the epilogue) confusing to me:
SPOILERS
What exactly was Hartig's involvement? Why did Thomsen keep secrets and then suddenly divulge them all? Why did Erik's version of his mother's death have him and Helen discover her collapsed and then use her phone to call an ambulance, when the plot required Helen to have asked Renate to call the emergency services for them and her forget to do so? - This led me to assume that Erik was implicated in some way.
Ultimately it was just too convoluted and there were just too many threads of wrong doing at the hospital (none of which I believed could really go on in Germany in the 21st century).
I don't think I'll read any more of these.
My reasons for this are mostly subjective, beginning with the title. I am a contrary soul, and when someone tells me point blank that he/she is my judge, I beg to differ. In addition, one of the storylines that I do not care for at all is the one in which the sins of the fathers are visited upon their children. I say, if you have a serious problem with your father and think he needs to die, then kill him, don't kill someone who doesn't have a thing to do with the situation. As you can see, Neuhaus did get a firm grip on my emotions with her plot and her killer, but it wasn't necessarily in a good way. It also didn't help that this book suffers from too much middle and could easily have lost around one hundred pages to tighten it up and heighten the suspense.
Yes, my dislike of this book is mainly subjective, so keep this in mind when you're trying to decide whether or not to read it. Your hot buttons may not be the same as mine.
Nach den ersten Seiten war ich bei diesem Taunuskrimi wieder in den Bann gezogen. Die Geschichte war sehr spannend geschrieben und man wusste lange nicht wer der Täter war. Einige Male führte Nele Neuhaus den Leser in die falsche Richtung und man dachte jetzt weiß man wer der Täter ist. Doch dann las man weiter und merkte das man mit seiner Vermutung anscheinend doch nicht richtig lag.
Die Beschreibungen der Orte sind sehr gut und anschaulich gelungen. Man fühlte sich, als sei man direkt dabei. Auch die Personen mit ihren Emotionen, ihren Ängsten, ihren Zweifeln wurden passend beschrieben.
Das Cover finde ich auch sehr gut gelungen. Die tiefroten Blutstropfen und der dunkle Wolkenhimmel ergeben schon einige schaurige Stimmung.
Ganze 2 Jahre musste man auf die Fortsetzung der Taunuskrimis warten und ich wurde mit keiner Seite enttäuscht. Nele Neuhaus hat auch hier wieder einen spannenden und fesselnden Krimi geschaffen.
5 von 5 Sterne
Another very exciting crime thriller by Nele Neuhaus, which I can highly recommend.