Status
Available
Call number
Genres
Publication
Mariner Books (2003), Edition: First Edition, Paperback, 368 pages
Description
Since its inception in 1915, the Best American series has become the premier annual showcase for the country's finest short fiction and nonfiction. For each volume, the very best pieces are selected by an editor who is widely recognized as a leading writer in his or her field, making the Best American series the most respected -- and most popular -- of its kind. Dave Eggers, who will be editing The Best American Nonrequired Reading annually, has once again chosen the best and least-expected fiction, nonfiction, satire, investigative reporting, alternative comics, and more from publications large, small, and on-line -- The Onion, The New Yorker, Shout, Time, Zoetrope, Tin House, Nerve.com,and McSweeney's, to name just a few. Read on for "Some of the best literature you haven't been reading . . . And it's fantastic. All of it." (St. Petersburg Times). Lynda Barry Jonathan Safran Foer Lisa Gabriele Andrea Lee J. T. Leroy Nasdijj ZZ Packer David Sedaris… (more)
User reviews
LibraryThing member Johnruexp
I was surprised at how TEDIOUS some of the selections are - more like typing than writing. Part of the "writing for the sake of writing" epidemic that Eggers seems to encourage in a certain population of writers.
Some good stuff hidden among the dross, however.
Some good stuff hidden among the dross, however.
LibraryThing member figre
When I read the 2006 Best American Non-required Reading collection, I knew I’d stumbled on something special (see the review). So, when I saw the 2003 version in a bookstore, I grabbed it quickly. And, an interesting set of comparisons ensued. First would be the comparison to its younger sibling.
In this collection, standouts include Ryan Boudinot’s “The Littlest Hitler” about the Halloween he dressed as Hitler; Mark Bowden’s “Tales of the Tyrant”, an insight to Saddam that, while it might be what we expect, is more than we knew; and David Drury’s story “Things we Knew When the House Caught Fire” which works at the level of kids not accepting the new kids, the new kids not accepting their roles, and trying to determine who really is better for their misunderstanding of what is going on around them. By the way, those are just the runners-up. “A Primer for the Punctuation of Heart Disease” mixes symbols with words (aren’t they really the same thing) to tell the story of families and impending deaths. “Touching Him” by Nasdijj is… Look, I can’t come up with the right words. It is about a foster father caring for a foster child with Aids. It talks about the fears and it talks about the pains. But it also talks about the intimacies of the two – about love. If I could explain it, I would have written it.
There’s more, too. David Sedaris is always great, and “Lost Boys” by John Verbos is just strange and, while I’m not sure what it was, I liked visiting it. And all this leads to the comparison to the 2006 version. Would you believe me if I said I didn’t like it as much? I guess that just goes to show the strength of the 2006 version because, this is good. The only real difference I can find is that, the weak items were weaker in 2003 than in 2006. And with the list of standouts I just provided, you can guess that the number of weak items is very small.
Show More
But, a more interesting comparison arises from my just having finished the 2003 Best American Essays (see the review.) Everything that was wrong with that collection – the pretentiousness, the rambling, the “art-or-art’s-sake” feel - disappears when someone just tries to collect good stories, essays, and etc. (And, yes, I meant to say “and etc.”) These collections seem to show that Eggers (whose McSweeney’s I have never been able to embrace) does not care so much about what the critics want, instead finding what might be considered popular (in the best spirit of the word) choices that you probably missed. In this collection, standouts include Ryan Boudinot’s “The Littlest Hitler” about the Halloween he dressed as Hitler; Mark Bowden’s “Tales of the Tyrant”, an insight to Saddam that, while it might be what we expect, is more than we knew; and David Drury’s story “Things we Knew When the House Caught Fire” which works at the level of kids not accepting the new kids, the new kids not accepting their roles, and trying to determine who really is better for their misunderstanding of what is going on around them. By the way, those are just the runners-up. “A Primer for the Punctuation of Heart Disease” mixes symbols with words (aren’t they really the same thing) to tell the story of families and impending deaths. “Touching Him” by Nasdijj is… Look, I can’t come up with the right words. It is about a foster father caring for a foster child with Aids. It talks about the fears and it talks about the pains. But it also talks about the intimacies of the two – about love. If I could explain it, I would have written it.
There’s more, too. David Sedaris is always great, and “Lost Boys” by John Verbos is just strange and, while I’m not sure what it was, I liked visiting it. And all this leads to the comparison to the 2006 version. Would you believe me if I said I didn’t like it as much? I guess that just goes to show the strength of the 2006 version because, this is good. The only real difference I can find is that, the weak items were weaker in 2003 than in 2006. And with the list of standouts I just provided, you can guess that the number of weak items is very small.
Show Less
LibraryThing member pecochran
This had some really good pieces, and a number of bad ones. I thought Jonathan Safran Foer inventing punctuation to tell his story was pretty silly. I didn't get the point of that at all. Pinkerton's piece on writing a suspense novel was hysterical, and Leroy's piece on Saddam Hussein was a very
Show More
good piece. Most of the rest of it was somewhere in between. Show Less
LibraryThing member JBD1
This one I was less impressed with. There are some excellent pieces: Sherman Alexie's on identity, Mark Bowden's profile of Saddam Hussein, Chuck Klosterman on a tribute band, and George Packer's on the discarded-clothing market come to mind. Many of the others didn't do much for me, but I'm still
Show More
glad I read them to get the full range of the collection. Show Less
Subjects
Original publication date
2003-10-10
Physical description
368 p.; 8.26 inches
ISBN
9780618246960