Status
Available
Call number
Publication
Helsinki : WSOY, 2008
Description
One morning in 1961, the residents of East Berlin found themselves cut off from family, friends and jobs in the West by a tangle of barbed wire that ruthlessly cut a city of four million in two. Within days the barbed wire became a 103-mile-long wall guarded by three hundred watchtowers. A physical manifestation of the Cold War that would stand for nearly thirty years, the Berlin Wall was the fault line between East and West on which rested the fate of all humanity. Historian Taylor weaves together official history, archival materials and personal accounts to tell the complete story of the Wall's rise and fall, from the postwar political tensions that created a divided Berlin to the internal and external pressures that led to the Wall's demise. He also explores the geopolitical ramifications, as well as the impact the Wall had on ordinary lives, still felt today.--From publisher description.… (more)
User reviews
LibraryThing member cushlareads
I gave this book 4 stars, which is really an average of 5 stars for content and 3 (barely) for the writing.
I found Taylor's style really annoying. There are lots of sentences. Without verbs. For dramatic effect. And it's a bit repetitive. Some of the translations are bizarre (e.g. High Burgomaster
Taylor presents a good overview of what happened in Germany and Berlin at the end of WW2. The East German regime was repressive from the start and funnily enough the East German people did not fall in love with communism and the SED (Communist party). Many tried to leave. After 1949, when the German Democratic Republic was created out of the Soviet zone, this became very difficult, except through West Berlin - if you could get to the airport there, you could get on a plane and leave, and thousands did. Berlin in turn was divided into 4 sectors in 1945, and there was more-or-less free flow of Berliners among the sectors. If you lived in the Russian sector, you could work in the other sectors and earn West German marks, or send your kids to school there - not without heavy criticism and accusations of being a traitor, but you could do it.
By 1961, the East German government was desperate to stop the flow of emigrants, and finally got the go-ahead from Stalin to put a barrier up around West Berlin, so that it was completely closed in. This happened in secret and overnight. Taylor goes on to describe the repression, the escape attempts, diplomatic negotiations and cold war politics, West and East German politics, and of course what happened at the end. If you're going to Berlin, or interested in the period, I would read this book as well as The File by Timothy Garten Ash, or Stasiland by Anna Funder.
I found Taylor's style really annoying. There are lots of sentences. Without verbs. For dramatic effect. And it's a bit repetitive. Some of the translations are bizarre (e.g. High Burgomaster
Show More
for mayor), and I did not really need to know that Lyndon Johnson ate oatmeal and melon for breakfast the day he was in Berlin. But most of the content is terrific. I've just come back from a trip to Berlin and it enriched my visit hugely. I filled it with sticky notes and then visited some of the streets, like Bernauerstrasse where the wall split the street. Taylor presents a good overview of what happened in Germany and Berlin at the end of WW2. The East German regime was repressive from the start and funnily enough the East German people did not fall in love with communism and the SED (Communist party). Many tried to leave. After 1949, when the German Democratic Republic was created out of the Soviet zone, this became very difficult, except through West Berlin - if you could get to the airport there, you could get on a plane and leave, and thousands did. Berlin in turn was divided into 4 sectors in 1945, and there was more-or-less free flow of Berliners among the sectors. If you lived in the Russian sector, you could work in the other sectors and earn West German marks, or send your kids to school there - not without heavy criticism and accusations of being a traitor, but you could do it.
By 1961, the East German government was desperate to stop the flow of emigrants, and finally got the go-ahead from Stalin to put a barrier up around West Berlin, so that it was completely closed in. This happened in secret and overnight. Taylor goes on to describe the repression, the escape attempts, diplomatic negotiations and cold war politics, West and East German politics, and of course what happened at the end. If you're going to Berlin, or interested in the period, I would read this book as well as The File by Timothy Garten Ash, or Stasiland by Anna Funder.
Show Less
LibraryThing member theuniversityofgav
New Year's Eve 2009/2010 I wanted to be on my own, as I have many New Year's Eves, but a few days before a good friend invited me over to be with his girlfriend and a female friend of theirs. Still reluctant, and ambivalent about the fact I was convinced they were trying to set me up, I accepted
This friend of theirs was a teacher, was convinced of her own intellectual brilliance, and had a tendency to micro-manage conversation until the whole evening became one long, dread, succession of parlour games. Who would we invite to the ideal dinner party (I hate dinner parties), Barack Obama apparently, to which my unenthused response earned me the assured "Don't you read Time". No, I don't. Another such game led somehow to us discussing what would be our Mastermind topic. Hers was Elvis, and she issued a torrent of facts (and those justifications masquarading as facts that are never far from a true fanatic's lips). B_____'s would be Rallying in the '90s. His girlfriend's, I think, would be something to do with the Berlin Wall. At any rate, one thing I took away from the evening, aside from my own unsuitability for company of any kind and my desire to be a perfect recluse, as I had more or less managed that half year, was that, though I had many special interests as fiercely obsessive as our Elvis aficionado's that night, I was master of none of them; the fact that I had managed one tenuously assimilated fact about the Berlin Wall that night, and that I had for many years had an interest in precisely this period of Central and Eastern European history, and the Cold War seemed particularly stark, and I played a game of Solitaire Humiliations with myself for a long while afterwards.
Soon after moving to North Wales I was walking around Bangor, a University town, and indeed, a university town I could have lived in had things turned out differently - for most of the summer, awaiting A-Level results, I had indeed believed I would end up at my second choice, studying English with Creative Writing, and looking back now I could see for sure it would have suited me better - and taking a look at the Oxfam, I could not hold back from buying Taylor's book on the very subject I had proven myself to not understand. One thought I depolyed against the compulsive purchase of the book was that I would never in a million years finish it. I don't do well with such long books. The faltering motivation and shifting priorities of my ADHD see to that. But it was no good.
Two, three months on, I am glad of that. The book was a slog. I stalled on it numerous times and, though I left myself notes and To Do lists, and though I picked up the book again and again and pushed myself on, my self conscious re-focusing sessions were difficult. Something changed perhaps when I got one hundred and fifty or so pages in and the wall was built. Suddenly the recondite machinations of the various political parties and cabals were thrown into sharp relief by the very real human stories of the individuals and groups on either side of the wall.
Unusually for me I zipped through the next few hundred pages, reading them quickly for me at any rate. The realities of events in the GDR and the larger than life characters of those such as Lyndon Johnson, Walter Ulbricht, John F Kennedy, Nikita Krushchev and, more particularly, those lesser known but, incredibly, equally rare individuals, are for me more enthralling than any political thriller.
It may well be that the events were enthralling enough to keep me reading despite the lacklustre text. There were few passages where Taylor's prose or delivery stood out and it struck me that perhaps at times the scarcely believable events could have been better served. Still, I am glad I persisted, and feel no less determined, at the end of it, that any future games of Solitaire Humiliations will not find me so ignorant of an area of history I should by now be pretty sure of.
Outside of the text I have a few of my usual bugbears. Acronyms and abbreviations can be opaque at the best of times, and histories concerning the Cold War especially so given the fact that many such are taken from the already perplexing initials of foreign institutions. At the very least I believe a history such as this ought to have a list of abbreviations used. Equally useful, though, would be a list of the key figures. It is not only those with ADHD like myself who may find themselves putting such a book as this aside for a time. It needs an investment of concentration and energy many people lack over a prolonged period. It can be difficult to remember a large cast of characters at the best of times.
Overall, though, reading this book has made me less intimidated by serious historical texts, less liable to persuade myself that I would be unable to make it through them, and indeed, more likely to persist. I may well seek out Taylor's more highly rated Dresden, and try again with such texts as Timothy Garton Ash's We The People and The Polish Revolution. Whatever my reservations, this itself must be a high recommendation.
Show More
and drove over.This friend of theirs was a teacher, was convinced of her own intellectual brilliance, and had a tendency to micro-manage conversation until the whole evening became one long, dread, succession of parlour games. Who would we invite to the ideal dinner party (I hate dinner parties), Barack Obama apparently, to which my unenthused response earned me the assured "Don't you read Time". No, I don't. Another such game led somehow to us discussing what would be our Mastermind topic. Hers was Elvis, and she issued a torrent of facts (and those justifications masquarading as facts that are never far from a true fanatic's lips). B_____'s would be Rallying in the '90s. His girlfriend's, I think, would be something to do with the Berlin Wall. At any rate, one thing I took away from the evening, aside from my own unsuitability for company of any kind and my desire to be a perfect recluse, as I had more or less managed that half year, was that, though I had many special interests as fiercely obsessive as our Elvis aficionado's that night, I was master of none of them; the fact that I had managed one tenuously assimilated fact about the Berlin Wall that night, and that I had for many years had an interest in precisely this period of Central and Eastern European history, and the Cold War seemed particularly stark, and I played a game of Solitaire Humiliations with myself for a long while afterwards.
Soon after moving to North Wales I was walking around Bangor, a University town, and indeed, a university town I could have lived in had things turned out differently - for most of the summer, awaiting A-Level results, I had indeed believed I would end up at my second choice, studying English with Creative Writing, and looking back now I could see for sure it would have suited me better - and taking a look at the Oxfam, I could not hold back from buying Taylor's book on the very subject I had proven myself to not understand. One thought I depolyed against the compulsive purchase of the book was that I would never in a million years finish it. I don't do well with such long books. The faltering motivation and shifting priorities of my ADHD see to that. But it was no good.
Two, three months on, I am glad of that. The book was a slog. I stalled on it numerous times and, though I left myself notes and To Do lists, and though I picked up the book again and again and pushed myself on, my self conscious re-focusing sessions were difficult. Something changed perhaps when I got one hundred and fifty or so pages in and the wall was built. Suddenly the recondite machinations of the various political parties and cabals were thrown into sharp relief by the very real human stories of the individuals and groups on either side of the wall.
Unusually for me I zipped through the next few hundred pages, reading them quickly for me at any rate. The realities of events in the GDR and the larger than life characters of those such as Lyndon Johnson, Walter Ulbricht, John F Kennedy, Nikita Krushchev and, more particularly, those lesser known but, incredibly, equally rare individuals, are for me more enthralling than any political thriller.
It may well be that the events were enthralling enough to keep me reading despite the lacklustre text. There were few passages where Taylor's prose or delivery stood out and it struck me that perhaps at times the scarcely believable events could have been better served. Still, I am glad I persisted, and feel no less determined, at the end of it, that any future games of Solitaire Humiliations will not find me so ignorant of an area of history I should by now be pretty sure of.
Outside of the text I have a few of my usual bugbears. Acronyms and abbreviations can be opaque at the best of times, and histories concerning the Cold War especially so given the fact that many such are taken from the already perplexing initials of foreign institutions. At the very least I believe a history such as this ought to have a list of abbreviations used. Equally useful, though, would be a list of the key figures. It is not only those with ADHD like myself who may find themselves putting such a book as this aside for a time. It needs an investment of concentration and energy many people lack over a prolonged period. It can be difficult to remember a large cast of characters at the best of times.
Overall, though, reading this book has made me less intimidated by serious historical texts, less liable to persuade myself that I would be unable to make it through them, and indeed, more likely to persist. I may well seek out Taylor's more highly rated Dresden, and try again with such texts as Timothy Garton Ash's We The People and The Polish Revolution. Whatever my reservations, this itself must be a high recommendation.
Show Less
LibraryThing member Scotland
The title of this book is a little deceiving, in that a good portion of the text deals with events prior to 1961. Not that this is a fault, Taylor actually gives a good accounting of the events that led up to the wall, including a brief history of Berlin and the German state. The period of 1945-61
What I thought was a little odd, was when I was 300 pages into the book, I was still on 1962/63. The actual life of the wall is only discussed in a few chapters, and for those intrigued by the cold war espionage legends of Check Point Charlie, that angle was not prominent in this book, although John Le Carre's name does arise a few times. The book mainly concentrates on the immigration, economic, and leadership issues surrounding the wall, the divided city of Berlin, and the divided nation of Germany, and using this theme, Taylor does an excellent job. His findings and conclusions seem to correlate with previous information I possessed about the topic, which allowed me to be comfortable with the credibility of the work.
On the whole, I would highly recommend this book. 450 pages may scare off the feint hearted, but the narration itself is not a very difficult read.
Show More
are discussed in detail, including the roles of the occupying powers, the city, and the two German states. A solid biography of the main players is presented, such as Ulbricht, Brandt, and Honicker. What I thought was a little odd, was when I was 300 pages into the book, I was still on 1962/63. The actual life of the wall is only discussed in a few chapters, and for those intrigued by the cold war espionage legends of Check Point Charlie, that angle was not prominent in this book, although John Le Carre's name does arise a few times. The book mainly concentrates on the immigration, economic, and leadership issues surrounding the wall, the divided city of Berlin, and the divided nation of Germany, and using this theme, Taylor does an excellent job. His findings and conclusions seem to correlate with previous information I possessed about the topic, which allowed me to be comfortable with the credibility of the work.
On the whole, I would highly recommend this book. 450 pages may scare off the feint hearted, but the narration itself is not a very difficult read.
Show Less
LibraryThing member bke
Not only covering the diplomatic and political background of the Wall, the author also interleaves personal stories of ordinary Berliners, creating dynamic history of what was an ugly scar on a city I love. I remember my first sight of the Wall in 1984, and watching its downfall on TV just 5 years
Show More
later. This was the best history of the Berlin Wall I have read. Show Less
LibraryThing member JesperCFS2
I really enjoyed reading this book. Taylor has a good 'flow' in his account and just the right dose - in my humble opinion - of personal remarks. If I had had the time I would have read it continuously
So, if you feel an irresistible urge to read about The Wall, this book is a very good choice. Go
So, if you feel an irresistible urge to read about The Wall, this book is a very good choice. Go
Show More
ahead and enjoy Show Less
LibraryThing member TheCrow2
A wall which divided a city and thousands of lives for decades and where dozens of people died. An easy to read and informative book about maybe the strangest symbolic monument of the XX. century.
Subjects
Awards
Prix Grand Témoin (2009)
Language
Original language
English
Original publication date
2006 (1e édition originale anglaise ∙ Bloomsbury)
2009-08-26 (1e traducitn et édition française ∙ Jean-Claude Lattès)
2011-08-25 (Réédition française, Tempus, Perrin)
Physical description
546 p.; 22.5 cm
ISBN
9789510331286